指南与共识免疫规划妇幼与学校卫生卫生政策与健康促进

运用行为改变轮与APEASE标准与利益相关方共同制定建议以解决学校免疫规划障碍

Operationalizing the Behaviour Change Wheel and APEASE criteria to co-develop recommendations with stakeholders to address barriers to school-based immunization programs.
指南 / 共识 · Vaccine · 2024-08-21

本研究整合混合方法研究结果,运用行为改变轮将发现映射为干预策略,与利益相关方共同制定建议以解决学校免疫规划障碍。初步形成26条建议,16名参与者采用APEASE标准(可接受性、实用性、有效性、可负担性、安全性、公平性)评分,其中一半建议在全部六项标准上得分≥80%,其余13条建议在一项或多项标准上得分中等。利益相关方对扩大电子同意书使用、扩大脑膜炎B疫苗项目及缓解学生焦虑的建议兴趣较高。

要点

  • 运用行为改变轮与APEASE标准共同制定26条解决学校免疫规划障碍的建议。
  • 16名参与者反馈中,一半建议在全部六项APEASE标准上得分≥80%。
  • 利益相关方对扩大电子同意书、脑膜炎B疫苗项目及缓解学生焦虑兴趣较高。

核心结论

  • 研究团队与利益相关方共同制定了一系列建议以改善学校免疫规划,任何单条或组合建议的实施需根据当地诊所流程、学校系统和卫生系统资源进行定制。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究整合混合方法研究结果,采用联合展示和叙述性总结,通过行为改变轮映射为干预策略,并将草案建议提供给同意参与后续研究阶段的既往混合方法研究参与者(n=26)征求反馈。

主要发现

  • 应用行为改变轮起草了26条基于证据和理论依据的建议以解决学校免疫规划障碍。
  • 16名参与者提供反馈,其中一半建议在全部六项APEASE标准上得分≥80%,其余13条建议在一项或多项标准上得分中等。
  • 利益相关方对扩大电子同意书使用、扩大脑膜炎B疫苗项目及缓解学生焦虑的建议兴趣较高。

关键数值与推荐

  • 参与者采用李克特量表对建议的可接受性、实用性、有效性、可负担性、安全性和公平性(APEASE)六项标准进行评分。
  • 26条建议中,一半在全部六项APEASE标准上得分≥80%,其余13条在一项或多项标准上得分中等。

临床怎么用

  • 任何单条或组合建议的实施需根据当地诊所流程、学校系统和卫生系统资源进行定制。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

INTRODUCTION: School-based immunization programs offer an accessible route to routine vaccines for students. During the COVID-19 pandemic, school closures to comply with public health measures had a drastic effect on school-based immunization program delivery and associated vaccine uptake. We sought to integrate findings from a mixed methods study to co-develop evidence-based and theory-informed recommendations with a diverse group of stakeholders (i.e., decision makers, healthcare providers, school staff, parents and adolescent students) to address barriers to new and existing school-based immunization programs. METHODS: Findings from a mixed methods study were integrated using a joint display and narrative summary. These findings were mapped through the Behaviour Change Wheel, a series of tools designed to facilitate the development of behaviour change interventions. Draft recommendations were provided to previous mixed methods study participants who consented to participating in future phases of the research study (n = 26). Feedback was captured using a Likert-scale survey of acceptability, practicality, effectiveness, affordability, safety and equity (APEASE) criteria, with feedback and additional insights captured using open-ended textboxes. Data was used to revise and finalize recommendations. RESULTS: Applying the Behaviour Change Wheel, we drafted 26 evidence-based, theory-informed recommendations to address barriers to school-based immunization programs. Participants (n = 16) provided feedback, with half of the recommendations scoring 80% or higher across all six APEASE criteria. The remaining 13 recommendations received a moderate score across one or more criteria. Stakeholders identified a high level of interest in expanding the use of e-consent forms, expanding programming to offer a meningitis B vaccine, and recommendations to ease student anxiety. CONCLUSION: We co-developed a range of recommendations to improve school-based immunization programs with stakeholders using data generated from a mixed methods study. Implementation of any single or combination of recommendations will need to be tailored to local clinic procedures, school system and health system resources.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gallant AJ, Steenbeek A, Halperin SA, et al. Operationalizing the Behaviour Change Wheel and APEASE criteria to co-develop recommendations with stakeholders to address barriers to school-based immunization programs. Vaccine. 2024. PMID: 39173194. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.126226

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。