漏报感染对回顾性队列研究疫苗有效性估计的影响
研究用随机个体模型模拟呼吸道病毒传播和大规模接种,评估漏报感染对回顾性队列研究疫苗有效性(VE)估计的偏倚。结果显示,报告率均匀时即使低至10%估计仍准确;攻击率超过50%或接种与未接种者漏报存在差异时,VE估计出现明显偏倚。
要点
- 报告率均匀时,即使低至10%,VE估计仍准确。
- 攻击率超过50%且报告均匀时,VE估计出现实质性向下偏倚。
- 接种与未接种者漏报存在轻度差异即可使VE估计明显偏倚。
核心结论
- 观察性研究中,高攻击率或接种与未接种者漏报差异可能导致VE估计偏倚。
- 研究强调监测数据质量和理解观察性研究偏倚对公共卫生决策的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究开发随机个体模型模拟呼吸道病毒传播动态和大规模接种活动。
- 基线场景为年攻击率22.5%、报告比30%,并探索14个替代场景,每个场景修改一个或多个基线假设。
- 利用模型产生的合成个体水平监测数据和接种登记,估计针对记录感染的VE,参照组为未接种者或近期接种者(接种后14天内)。
- 通过比较估计值与模型假设的已知VE量化偏倚。
主要发现
- 报告率均匀时,即使低至10%,VE估计仍准确。
- 攻击率低于50%且报告均匀时,VE估计准确。
- 攻击率超过50%且报告均匀时,VE估计出现实质性向下偏倚。
- 接种与未接种者报告率存在轻度差异时,若接种者病例更可能被报告则VE估计向下偏倚,否则向上偏倚,尤其以未接种者为参照时。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Surveillance data and vaccination registries are widely used to provide real-time vaccine effectiveness (VE) estimates, which can be biased due to underreported (i.e. under-ascertained and under-notified) infections. Here, we investigate how the magnitude and direction of this source of bias in retrospective cohort studies vary under different circumstances, including different levels of underreporting, heterogeneities in underreporting across vaccinated and unvaccinated, and different levels of pathogen circulation. METHODS: We developed a stochastic individual-based model simulating the transmission dynamics of a respiratory virus and a large-scale vaccination campaign. Considering a baseline scenario with 22.5% yearly attack rate and 30% reporting ratio, we explored fourteen alternative scenarios, each modifying one or more baseline assumptions. Using synthetic individual-level surveillance data and vaccination registries produced by the model, we estimated the VE against documented infection taking as reference either unvaccinated or recently vaccinated individuals (within 14 days post-administration). Bias was quantified by comparing estimates to the known VE assumed in the model. RESULTS: VE estimates were accurate when assuming homogeneous reporting ratios, even at low levels (10%), and moderate attack rates (<50%). A substantial downward bias in the estimation arose with homogeneous reporting and attack rates exceeding 50%. Mild heterogeneities in reporting ratios between vaccinated and unvaccinated strongly biased VE estimates, downward if cases in vaccinated were more likely to be reported and upward otherwise, particularly when taking as reference unvaccinated individuals. CONCLUSIONS: In observational studies, high attack rates or differences in underreporting between vaccinated and unvaccinated may result in biased VE estimates. This study underscores the critical importance of monitoring data quality and understanding biases in observational studies, to more adequately inform public health decisions.
引用
- Sacco C, Manica M, Marziano V, et al. The impact of underreported infections on vaccine effectiveness estimates derived from retrospective cohort studies. Int J Epidemiol. 2024. PMID: 38847783. doi:10.1093/ije/dyae077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。