注意差距:患者自述的疫苗接种观念与其全科医生评估之间的一致性
该研究基于31名全科医生和540对医患在就诊开始时分别填写的简短问卷,评估医生对患者疫苗犹豫的评判与患者自述观念的相关性。结果显示医生评估与患者自述在疫苗安全性、有效性和「支持接种」三个维度上均呈弱相关(Kendall tau 0.199–0.365,p<0.001),医生能正确识别83.4%的高观念患者,但仅能正确识别54.5%的低观念患者。
要点
- 医生评估与患者自述在三个疫苗观念维度上均呈弱相关(tau 0.199–0.365)。
- 医生对患者疫苗观念的评估在医生为男性、患者为男性及双方均为男性时更积极。
- 医生正确识别83.4%的高观念患者,但仅正确识别54.5%的低观念患者。
核心结论
- 医生倾向于正确识别对疫苗接种持最积极观念的患者,但不能正确识别持最不积极观念的患者。
研究设计与样本
- 研究基于就诊开始时由全科医生和患者私下分别填写的两份简短纸质问卷,共纳入31名医生和540对医患。
- 医生问卷用三个定量非分级视觉量表(按0–100分分析)评估患者对疫苗安全性、疫苗有效性和「支持接种」的观念;患者问卷用相同量表表达自身观念。
主要发现
- 医生评估与患者自述在三个维度上均存在相关性(Kendall检验:疫苗有效性 tau=0.199,p<0.001;疫苗安全性 tau=0.234,p<0.001;支持接种 tau=0.365,p<0.001)。
- 医生评估与患者自述之间的中位绝对差异在三个维度(疫苗安全性、疫苗有效性和「支持接种」)上介于9至11(0–100量表)。
- 医生对患者观念的评估在医生为男性(对比女性)、患者为男性(对比女性)及双方均为男性(对比双方均为女性)时更积极。
- 医生正确分类了83.4%的高疫苗安全性和有效性观念患者(两个量表均>75/100),但仅正确分类了54.5%的低观念患者(两个量表均<75/100)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The high level of vaccine hesitancy reported in the French population may lead general practitioners to anticipate difficult discussions on this topic. We aimed to assess the extent to which general practitioners' evaluation of their patients' vaccine hesitancy was correlated with the real vaccine hesitancy expressed by these patients. METHODS: The study was based on two brief paper questionnaires completed in private by the general practitioner and the patient at the beginning of a medical appointment: one for the physician to evaluate on three quantitative and non-graduated visual scales (then analysed as a 0-100 scale) their patients' perceptions regarding vaccine safety, vaccine efficacy and 'being in favour of vaccination'; and one for the patient to express their perceptions for the same three axes using the same scales. RESULTS: Overall, 31 physicians participated in the study, with 540 physician-patient pairs being included. The physicians' evaluation of patient perceptions was more positive when the physician was male (vs female), when the patient was male (vs female) and when both were males (vs both females). The median differences (in absolute values) between the physician evaluations and the patient perceptions were between 9 and 11 (on the 0-100 scale) for the three axes (vaccine safety, vaccine efficacy and 'being in favour'). A correlation was observed between the physicians' evaluation and the patients' declaration (Kendall test: vaccine efficacy: tau = 0.199, p < 0.001; vaccine safety: tau = 0.234, p < 0.001; being in favour of vaccination: tau = 0.365, p < 0.001). Physicians correctly classified 83.4 % of the patients with high perceptions of vaccine safety and efficacy (>75/100 for both scales) but only 54.5 % of those with low perceptions (<75/100 for both scales). CONCLUSION: Physicians tend to correctly identify patients with the most favourable perceptions about vaccination but not those with the least favourable perceptions.
引用
- Lescop J, Pennes B, Epaulard O, et al. Mind the gap: Concordance between perceptions regarding vaccination as declared by patients and their evaluation by their general practitioner. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 38065770. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.11.065
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。