欧洲老年人与普通人群新冠疫苗强制接种令提升接种率的效果:受控中断时间序列分析
该研究采用受控中断时间序列分析,评估奥地利、希腊、意大利新冠疫苗强制接种令对首剂接种率的影响。希腊和意大利的强制接种令宣布后,目标年龄组接种率较对照组显著上升,但奥地利未见明显上升;研究结束时三国目标人群仍有未接种者,接种缺口未完全弥合。
要点
- 希腊≥60岁组强制接种令宣布后接种率相对50-59岁对照组显著上升(RR=4.36)。
- 意大利≥50岁组强制接种令宣布后接种率相对25-49岁对照组显著上升(RR=2.90)。
- 奥地利≥18岁人群强制接种令宣布后未观察到接种率明显上升。
核心结论
- 在希腊和意大利,强制接种令的简单宣布即快速提升了目标年龄组的新冠疫苗接种率,但未完全弥合接种缺口;奥地利未观察到类似效果。
- 强制接种似乎能有效针对自满情绪,但对疫苗犹豫效果有限,其公共卫生获益需与对信心和信任的可能不利影响相权衡。
研究设计与样本
- 受控中断时间序列分析,评估2021年第35周至2022年第50周期间首剂疫苗接种率。
- 希腊目标组为≥60岁人群,对照组为50-59岁人群;意大利目标组为≥50岁人群,对照组为25-49岁人群。
- 奥地利因疫苗强制令针对所有≥18岁成年人,故采用非受控分析。
主要发现
- 希腊目标年龄组强制接种令宣布后接种率较对照组显著上升(RR=4.36,95%CI:3.57-5.32),效应持续整个研究期。
- 意大利目标年龄组强制接种令宣布后接种率较对照组显著上升(RR=2.90,95%CI:2.37-3.56),效应持续整个研究期。
- 希腊强制接种令归因的首剂接种为176,428剂(95%CI:164,097-187,226),意大利为316,192剂(95%CI:282,467-346,678),其中大部分发生在强制令生效之前。
- 奥地利强制接种令宣布后未观察到接种率明显上升。
- 研究结束时,希腊≥60岁人群9.5%、意大利≥50岁人群4.9%、奥地利≥18岁人群13.8%仍未接种。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: During the COVID-19 pandemic, three European countries (Austria, Greece, Italy) announced and/or implemented mandatory COVID-19 vaccination for high-risk groups in the general population. Besides the ethical justification for this policy, it is important to assess and quantify the effectiveness of the mandate in raising vaccination rates. METHODS: Controlled interrupted time series analysis of first-dose vaccination rates in the targeted age groups (Greece: ≥60 years; Italy: ≥50 years) relative to a control group (Greece: 50-59 years; Italy: 25-49 years) between week 35/2021 and week 50/2022. For Austria an uncontrolled analysis was performed, as the vaccine mandate targeted all adults ≥18 years. RESULTS: Announcement of mandatory vaccination substantially increased vaccination rates in the targeted age groups compared to control in both Greece (RR = 4.36, 95 % CI: 3.57-5.32) and Italy (RR = 2.90, 95 % CI: 2.37-3.56), an effect which persisted throughout the study period. There were 176,428 (95 % CI: 164,097-187,226) mandate-attributable first-dose vaccinations in Greece and 316,192 (95 % CI: 282,467-346,678) in Italy, most of which occurred before the mandate came into effect. In Austria no discernible increase in vaccination rates was observed after the announcement of mandatory vaccination. At the end of the study period, 9.5 % of ≥60 year-olds in Greece, 4.9 % of ≥50 year-olds in Italy and 13.8 % of ≥18 year-olds in Austria remained unvaccinated. CONCLUSIONS: In Greece and Italy - though not in Austria - simple announcement of a vaccine mandate rapidly increased COVID-19 vaccination rates in the targeted age groups, without fully closing the vaccination gap. Mandatory vaccination appears to effectively target complacency but not vaccine hesitancy, and its public health benefits need to be weighted against possible detrimental effects on confidence and trust.
引用
- Lytras T, Di Gregorio AAA, Apostolopoulos D, et al. Effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccine mandates in raising vaccination rates among the elderly and general population in Europe: Controlled interrupted time series analysis. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 38081753. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.12.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。