文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

学校疫苗强制令中的教育组成部分:一项环境扫描

Education components of school vaccine mandates: An environmental scan.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2023-11-02

该环境扫描旨在查找、梳理并综合18个富裕的经济合作与发展组织(OECD)对比国家中学校疫苗强制令(SVM)教育组成部分的存在、形式与影响。结果显示,18个对比国家中9个有现行SVM,但仅加拿大(n=2)和美国(n=9)存在教育组成部分,且政策制定在省/州层面;最早于2011年实施,最新尚未实施。教育组成部分作为获得非医疗豁免的要求,形式包括阅读并签署信息文件、由卫生专业人员提供咨询或信息会议、或完成在线模块;同行评审研究表明面对面会议与至少短期疫苗接种率提高和非医疗豁免减少相关,在线模块数据提示类似影响但研究有限。

要点

  • 18个对比国家中9个有现行学校疫苗强制令,仅加拿大(n=2)和美国(n=9)有教育组成部分。
  • 教育组成部分作为非医疗豁免要求,形式含签署信息文件、卫生专业人员咨询或在线模块。
  • 面对面会议与至少短期接种率提高及非医疗豁免减少相关,在线模块证据有限。

核心结论

  • 带有教育组成部分的学校疫苗强制令不常见,但自2011年以来有所增加。
  • 教育组成部分的细节各不相同,尽管在线模块涵盖的主题相对一致。
  • 现有证据提示实施学校疫苗强制令教育组成部分与至少短期非医疗豁免减少相关,但需要额外研究来随访和确认,尤其是关于在线教育模块。

研究设计与样本

  • 该环境扫描在18个富裕的经济合作与发展组织(OECD)对比国家中查找、梳理并综合关于学校疫苗强制令教育组成部分的存在、形式和影响的证据。

主要发现

  • 在18个对比国家中9个有现行学校疫苗强制令,但教育组成部分仅见于加拿大(n=2)和美国(n=9),政策制定在省/州层面。
  • 最早的教育组成部分于2011年实施,最新的尚未实施。
  • 教育组成部分被用作获得学校疫苗强制令非医疗豁免的要求,涉及阅读并签署信息文件、由卫生专业人员(公共卫生工作者或持照提供者如家庭医生)提供咨询或信息会议、或完成在线模块。
  • 关于面对面会议的同行评审研究提示与至少短期疫苗接种率提高和非医疗豁免减少相关。
  • 关于在线模块教育组成部分的可用数据提示类似影响,但迄今研究有限。

关键数值与推荐

  • 世界卫生组织成员国中43%报告有某种形式的学校疫苗强制令,但其细节各异。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 关于在线模块教育组成部分的可用数据提示类似影响,但迄今研究有限。
  • 需要额外研究来随访和确认,尤其是关于在线教育模块。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: School vaccine mandates (SVMs) are population health interventions that require monitoring and communicating about vaccination of school-aged children, with an aim of controlling infectious disease outbreaks. While 43 % of World Health Organization member states report having some sort of SVM, their details vary. A newer element of some SVMs is an "education component" requiring compulsory information, education, or counseling of parents/guardians who decline to vaccinate their children for non-medical reasons. METHODS: This environmental scan sought, mapped, and synthesized evidence on the existence, format, and impacts of education components of SVMs in 18 affluent Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development comparator countries. FINDINGS: We found current SVMs in nine of the 18 comparator countries, but education components to those SVMs only in Canada (n = 2) and the U.S. (n = 9), where such policies were made at the provincial/state level. The earliest was implemented in 2011 and most recent has not yet been implemented. Education components were used as requirements for obtaining non-medical exemptions from SVMs, and involved either an informational paper to be read and signed, a counseling or information session from a health professional (public health worker or licensed provider such as family doctor), or an online module to be completed. Peer-reviewed research on in-person sessions suggests association with at least short-term increased vaccine uptake and reduction of non-medical exemptions. Available data on online module education components suggests similar impacts, but research to date is limited. CONCLUSION: SVMs with educational components are uncommon but have been increasing since 2011. The details of these education components vary, although topics covered in online modules are relatively consistent. Evidence to date suggests at least short-term reduction in non-medical exemptions associated with implementation of SVM education components, but additional research is required to follow-up and confirm, especially as regards online education modules.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Greyson D, Goh G. Education components of school vaccine mandates: An environmental scan. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37923695. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.09.058

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。