提高医护人员免疫接种接受度的干预措施:一项系统综述
本系统综述评估与无干预或其他干预相比,提高医护人员免疫接种接受度的干预措施的效果,检索截至2022年3月,纳入随机对照试验、整群随机对照试验、前后对照研究和中断时间序列研究,进行描述性分析和荟萃分析,并采用GRADE评估证据质量。共纳入3项随机对照试验、6项整群随机对照试验和4项中断时间序列研究,干预措施多样,许多含教育成分。基于所审查的证据,政策干预、针对性多成分策略、针对管理层的定制项目、由医生提供教育并配合疫苗“倡导者”以及个体决策分析可能是提高医护人员接种比例的有效策略。合格研究有限,限制了证据的合成与解释;无研究评估立法效果,也无研究单独评估激励措施或仅关注改善接种可及性;所有研究被判定为偏倚风险不明确或高。
要点
- 共纳入3项随机对照试验、6项整群随机对照试验和4项中断时间序列研究,干预措施多样。
- 政策干预、针对性多成分策略、针对管理层的定制项目、医生教育配合疫苗“倡导者”及个体决策分析可能是有效策略。
- 所有研究偏倚风险为不明确或高,无研究评估立法、单独激励或仅改善接种可及性的效果。
核心结论
- 评估提高医护人员疫苗接种的干预措施的稳健研究很少。
- 本系统综述的局限性在于干预措施多样、报告不充分且少有足够相似性以合并评估。
- 需要更多关于提高医护人员疫苗接种的干预措施效果的研究,应涉及多种疫苗而不仅是流感疫苗。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索截至2022年3月,采用预先建立的检索策略。
- 纳入随机对照试验、整群随机对照试验、前后对照研究和中断时间序列研究。
- 描述性描述研究,并在适当情况下采用固定效应或随机效应模型进行荟萃分析。
- 评估每项研究的偏倚风险,并使用GRADE评估每个比较的证据质量。
主要发现
- 共鉴定出3项随机对照试验、6项整群随机对照试验和4项中断时间序列研究。
- 干预措施多样,许多包含教育成分。
- 所有研究被判定为偏倚风险不明确或高。
关键数值与推荐
- 基于所审查的证据,以下可能是增加医护人员接种比例的有效策略:政策干预、针对性和多成分策略、针对管理层的定制项目、由医生提供教育并配合疫苗“倡导者”以及个体决策分析。
- 无研究评估立法的有效性。
- 未发现单独评估激励措施有效性的研究,也未发现仅关注改善疫苗接种可及性的研究。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 合格研究有限,限制了发现的合成与解释。
- 无研究评估立法的有效性。
- 未发现单独评估激励措施有效性的研究,也未发现仅关注改善疫苗接种可及性的研究。
- 所有研究被判定为偏倚风险不明确或高。
- 干预措施多样、报告不充分且少有足够相似性以合并评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: This systemic review aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of interventions for increasing the uptake of immunisation in healthcare workers (HCWs) compared to no or alternative interventions. METHODS: A systematic review was undertaken (until March 2022) using a search strategy established a priori to capture studies that examined the effect of interventions on vaccination levels in HCWs. We included randomised controlled trials (RCT), cluster RCTs, controlled before-after (CBA) studies and interrupted time-series (ITS) studies. We described studies descriptively and synthesized results with a fixed-effect or random-effects model meta-analysis, where appropriate. The risk of bias was assessed for each study; the quality evidence per comparison was assessed using Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE). RESULTS: We identified three RCTs, six cluster RCTs and four ITS studies. There was a diverse range of interventions; many included an educational component. Based on the evidence examined the following may be effective strategies in increasing the proportion of HCWs vaccinated: policy interventions, targeted and multicomponent strategies, tailored programs directed at management, physician delivered education with a vaccine 'champion' and individual decision analysis. Limited eligible studies restricted synthesis and interpretation of findings. No studies evaluated the effectiveness of legislation. Nor did we find studies evaluating the effectiveness of incentives on their own or studies focusing solely on improving access to vaccination. We judged all the studies as either unclear or high risk of bias. CONCLUSION: Few robust studies that evaluate interventions to increase vaccination in HCWs are available. A limitation of this systematic review is that interventions are diverse, poorly reported and few were sufficiently alike to combine in an evaluation. More research on the effects of interventions to increase vaccination in HCWs is required, this should address a variety of vaccines and not just influenza vaccination.
引用
- Tuckerman J, Riley K, Straube S, et al. Interventions for increasing the uptake of immunisations in healthcare workers: A systematic review. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37527954. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.07.064
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。