文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

政治争吵掩盖疫苗倡导:博索纳罗执政期间巴西推特上反疫苗者如何框定疫苗辩论

Political quarrel overshadows vaccination advocacy: How the vaccine debate on Brazilian Twitter was framed by anti-vaxxers during Bolsonaro administration.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2023-08-06

研究分析2021年12月9日至2022年2月9日巴西推特上超百万条推文和四百万条转推,选取1500条高影响力(>500次转推)影响者推文进行内容分析,发现反疫苗运动在框定推特讨论上更成功,而支持疫苗的影响者反应缺乏条理,主要批评反疫苗行为而非推广疫苗。

要点

  • 反疫苗运动在推特讨论框定上比支持疫苗方更成功。
  • 反疫苗者将新冠话题嵌入民粹主义、反科学和反传统媒体 discourse。
  • 支持疫苗影响者更多转推,但主要批评反疫苗者而非推广疫苗。

核心结论

  • 反疫苗运动在框定推特讨论上更成功,尽管支持疫苗影响者被更多转推。
  • 作者认为协调良好的健康传播者网络与简报充分的社交媒体影响者及事实核查来源合作,能更有效预防公众接触疫苗错误信息。

研究设计与样本

  • 收集2021年12月9日至2022年2月9日巴西推特上超一百万条推文和四百万条转推。
  • 从样本中选取1500条高影响力(>500次转推)影响者推文进行内容分析。
  • 识别出支持疫苗和反对疫苗两个界限分明的群体。

主要发现

  • 支持疫苗的影响者被转推次数多于反疫苗者。
  • 反疫苗运动在框定推特讨论上更成功。
  • 新冠话题成为反疫苗者推动的民粹主义、反科学和反传统媒体话语的政治极化目标。
  • 支持疫苗影响者反应缺乏条理,聚焦于批评反疫苗行为者、态度和政策而非推广疫苗。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为协调良好的科学中心和卫生机构健康传播者网络,与简报充分的社交媒体影响者及事实核查来源合作,能更有效预防公众接触疫苗错误信息。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Despite Brazil's tradition of successful mass immunization programs, the country has been experiencing alarming declines in vaccination coverage, especially among children. That is aggravated by the growth of anti-vaccine movements and the spread of health misinformation in social media in the last decade, which have worsened during the COVID-19 outbreak. Several reports link populism and far-right politicians to anti-vaccination support worldwide, which was also the case in Brazil during president Jair Bolsonaro's administration. This project aimed to identify the circulating pro and anti-vaccine narratives in Portuguese on Twitter, during a crucial decision-making period regarding childhood vaccination in Brazil, from December 9, 2021, until February 9, 2022. From the over one million tweets and four million retweets collected, we identified two well-defined groups, one in favor and another against vaccination. Within the sample, we selected 1500 influencer tweets with the highest impact (>500 retweets) and conducted content analysis. Although the pro-vaccine influencers were more retweeted than anti-vaxxer ones, we observed that anti-vaccine movements were more succesful in framing discussions on Twitter. The subject of COVID-19 was the target of political polarization embedded in populist, anti-science and anti-traditional media discourses promoted by anti-vaxxers. As a counterpart, the pro-vaccine influencers reacted inarticulately, focusing on criticizing the anti-vaccination actors, attitudes, and policies instead of promoting vaccines. Based on reults, we claim that a well-coordinated network of health communicators from science centers and health institutions, in partnership with properly briefed social media influencers and fact-checking sources, would more efectively pre-tempt the public about vaccine misinformation.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Verjovsky M, Barreto MP, Carmo I, et al. Political quarrel overshadows vaccination advocacy: How the vaccine debate on Brazilian Twitter was framed by anti-vaxxers during Bolsonaro administration. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37550146. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.07.075

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。