文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

COVID-19证书要求对疫苗接种模式及未来接种意愿的影响:法国成人横断面研究

Impact of a COVID-19 certificate requirement on vaccine uptake pattern and intention for future vaccination. A cross-sectional study among French adults.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2023-07-20

2021年8月法国实施COVID-19证书要求(接种/康复/检测)以进入特定场所并对职业群体强制接种。基于972名18-75岁成人网络问卷的横断面研究显示,85.7%已接种或意愿接种,其中3.6%仅因证书/强制接种;证书要求降低了接种状态与年轻及低信任度的负关联,但可能加剧无职业活动者的隔离,且未负面影响未来接种意愿。

要点

  • 85.7%受访者已接种或意愿接种,仅3.6%纯粹因证书/强制要求接种。
  • 观察情况下,对当局信任是中高 vs 低者接种状态的唯一显著决定因素(aPR=1.39)。
  • 仅因证书接种者对未来COVID-19疫苗的意愿显著高于未接种者(aPR=6.41)。

核心结论

  • 激励-强制政策减少了接种状态与年轻及低信任度之间的负关联,但可能加剧无职业活动者的隔离,且未负面影响未来COVID-19接种意愿。

研究设计与样本

  • 2021年8月下旬,法国18-75岁成人代表性样本完成网络问卷的横断面研究,共纳入972名参与者。
  • 采用多变量泊松回归估计调整患病率比(aPR),并按自述接种原因分类接种者,构建反事实接种状态。

主要发现

  • 972名参与者中,85.7%已接种或意愿接种;3.6%仅因证书/强制要求接种,17.7%主要因证书/强制要求加其他原因接种,64.4%主要因其他原因接种。
  • 反事实情境下,年长者较年轻者接种可能性显著更高(aPR=1.35),对当局COVID-19危机管理信任中高 vs 低者接种可能性显著更高(aPR=2.04)。
  • 观察情境下,信任是中高 vs 低的唯一显著接种状态决定因素(aPR=1.39)。
  • 无真实接种动机者中,在职人员比无职业活动者更可能屈从于证书要求(aPR=3.76)。
  • 仅因证书接种者较未接种者更可能表达未来COVID-19接种意愿(aPR=6.41)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者建议未来疫苗激励政策应特别关注对当局信任度低的人群。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: In August 2021, France enacted a COVID-19 certificate requirement (vaccination/recovery/test) to access specific services, with mandates for professional groups. We evaluated the impact of this incentive-coercive policy in terms of vaccine uptake equality, future vaccine intention and confidence in authorities' crisis management. METHODS: In late August 2021, a representative sample of adults (18-75 years) completed an internet-based questionnaire. We classified vaccinated participants by stated reasons for vaccination and estimated adjusted prevalence ratios (aPR) using multivariable Poisson regression. Counterfactual vaccine status assumed non-vaccination of those vaccinated for the certificate. We analysed the association of free-text testimonial themes with level of confidence in authorities. RESULTS: Among 972 participants, 85.7% were vaccinated or intended vaccination: 3.6% only for certificate/mandate, 17.7% mainly for certificate/mandate plus other reasons, and 64.4% mainly for other reasons. In the counterfactual situation, vaccine uptake would have been significantly more likely among older vs. younger participants (aPR = 1.35) and among those with moderate-high vs. low levels of confidence in authorities for COVID-19 crisis management (aPR = 2.04). In the observed situation, confidence was the only significant determinant of vaccine status (moderate-high vs. low, aPR = 1.39). Among those without genuine motivation for vaccination, professionally active persons were more likely to have ceded to the certificate requirement (aPR = 3.76). Those vaccinated only for the certificate were more likely to express future COVID-19 vaccine intention than unvaccinated persons (aPR = 6.41). Themes significantly associated with lower confidence were criticism of morality (aPR = 1.76) and poor communication by the authorities (aPR = 1.66). CONCLUSION: The incentive-coercive policy has reduced the negative association of vaccine status with younger age and low confidence in authorities, but may have reinforced isolation of professionally inactive persons. The requirement did not negatively impact future COVID-19 vaccine intention. Future vaccine-incentive policies should pay special attention to populations with low levels of confidence in authorities.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Araujo-Chaveron L, Sicsic J, Moffroid H, et al. Impact of a COVID-19 certificate requirement on vaccine uptake pattern and intention for future vaccination. A cross-sectional study among French adults. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37481404. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.07.002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。