某大型学术医院COVID-19疫苗强制令实施前后的疫苗接种率:按种族/族裔和患者接触水平的趋势
该队列研究纳入费城一家大型学术医院的10889名员工,随访时间为2020年12月16日至2021年10月31日。研究发现,疫苗强制令宣布前疫苗系列完成率为86.0%,实施后升至98.7%;强制令宣布后,黑人、其他/多种族背景者和西班牙裔的疫苗系列完成率增幅最大,分别为35.6%、22.4%和10.8%。结论提示强制令在减少犹豫和提高医护人员高接种率方面可能发挥重要作用。
要点
- 疫苗强制令实施后,医护人员疫苗系列完成率从86.0%升至98.7%。
- 强制令宣布后,黑人、其他/多种族背景者和西班牙裔的疫苗系列完成率增幅最大。
- 因疫苗强制令获批医疗或宗教豁免的员工为64人(<0.6%),38人(<0.4%)离职。
核心结论
- 这些结果提示,强制令可能对机构具有挑战性且执行不受欢迎,但在减少犹豫和提高医护人员高接种率方面可能发挥重要作用,医护人员因就业而面临COVID-19高风险,且可能成为疾病传播给患者的来源。
研究设计与样本
- 在费城一家大型学术医院中进行的队列研究,纳入10889名医院员工,随访时间为2020年12月16日至2021年10月31日。
主要发现
- 疫苗强制令宣布前疫苗系列完成率为86.0%,强制令实施后增至98.7%。
- 强制令宣布前,疫苗系列完成率最高的群体为亚裔(96.2%)、白人(94.0%)、男性(89.7%)、≥65岁员工(95.2%)和直接接触患者的员工(医生99.0%,护士93.3%)。
- 强制令宣布后,疫苗系列完成率增幅最大的群体为黑人(35.6%)、其他/多种族背景者(22.4%)和西班牙裔(10.8%),以及一些或没有直接患者接触的员工(24.5%和18.3%)。
- 因COVID-19疫苗强制令获批医疗或宗教豁免的员工为64人(<0.6%),38人(<0.4%)离职(8人自愿,30人非自愿)。
- 在强制令下接种疫苗者与离职者之间,未观察到按年龄、性别或种族/族裔的临床意义差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 疫苗系列完成率在强制令宣布前为86.0%,实施后为98.7%。
- 强制令宣布前疫苗系列完成率:亚裔96.2%,白人94.0%,男性89.7%,≥65岁员工95.2%,医生99.0%,护士93.3%。
- 强制令宣布后疫苗系列完成率增幅:黑人35.6%,其他/多种族背景者22.4%,西班牙裔10.8%,一些直接患者接触者24.5%,无直接患者接触者18.3%。
- 医疗或宗教豁免获批64人(<0.6%),离职38人(<0.4%;8人自愿,30人非自愿)。
临床怎么用
- 医院教育举措(包括市政厅会议和与疫苗接种率最低的黑人和西班牙裔员工讨论)似乎提高了接种率。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To assess vaccine coverage rates before and after implementation of a COVID-19 vaccine mandate among Health care Personnel (HCP) and demographic characteristics associated with vaccine uptake Design, Setting, and Participants: Cohort study conducted among 10,889 hospital employees followed from Dec 16, 2020 - October 31, 2021, at a large academic hospital in Philadelphia. MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES: Time to COVID-19 vaccination and vaccine series completion rates before and after implementation of a COVID-19 vaccine mandate based on age, gender, race/ethnicity, and level of patient contact/occupational group. RESULTS: The vaccination series completion rate was 86.0% prior to mandate announcement, and increased to 98.7% after mandate implementation. Rates before mandate announcement were highest among Asians (96.2%), Whites (94.0%), males (89.7%), employees ≥ 65 years of age (95.2%), and employees with direct patient care (physicians, 99.0%, and nurses, 93.3%). Hospital educational initiatives (including Town Halls and discussions with Black and Hispanic employees with the lowest vaccination rates) appeared to improve uptake. The largest increase in series completion after mandate announcement occurred among Blacks, those of other/multiracial backgrounds, and Hispanics (35.6%, 22.4%, and 10.8%, respectively) as well as those with some or no direct patient contact (24.5% and 18.3%, respectively). Medical or religious exemptions were approved for 64 (<0.6%) employees and 38 (<0.4%) left their positions (8 voluntary, 30 involuntary) specifically due to the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. No clinically meaningful differences by age, gender, or race/ethnicity for those who were vaccinated under the mandate versus those who left their positions were noted. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: These results suggest that while mandates may be challenging to institutions and enforcement unpopular, they play an important role in reducing hesitancy and securing high vaccination rates among HCP, a group at high risk of COVID-19 given their employment and who can be a source of disease transmission to patients.
引用
- Green-McKenzie J, Shofer FS, Kruse G, et al. COVID-19 vaccine uptake before and after a vaccine mandate at a major academic hospital: Trends by race/ethnicity and level of patient contact. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37517911. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.07.032
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。