加纳、莫桑比克和巴基斯坦的疫苗浪费:四种疫苗的浪费率评估及疫苗浪费的背景、原因、驱动因素与知识、态度和实践
本研究在加纳(48个服务点)、莫桑比克(36个)和巴基斯坦(46个)的疫苗接种服务点,采用前瞻性每日和每月疫苗使用数据录入表、横断面调查和深度访谈,评估四种疫苗的浪费率及相关背景、原因和知识态度实践。结果显示,单剂瓶或开封后可冷藏保存四周的多剂瓶疫苗的月度开瓶浪费率估计为0.08%至3%,开封后六小时内丢弃剩余剂次的多剂瓶疫苗平均浪费率为5%至33%,以含麻疹成分疫苗最高。尽管国家指南建议即使只有一名儿童也打开疫苗瓶,但开封后六小时内丢弃的多剂瓶疫苗有时比单剂瓶或可保存四周的多剂瓶疫苗更少被提供,可能导致错失接种机会。封闭瓶浪费虽相对罕见,但个别情况可造成大量损失。卫生工作者报告对疫苗浪费追踪和报告方法知识不足。
要点
- 单剂瓶或开封后可冷藏四周的多剂瓶疫苗月度开瓶浪费率为0.08%至3%。
- 开封后六小时内丢弃的多剂瓶疫苗平均浪费率为5%至33%,含麻疹成分疫苗最高。
- 开封后六小时内丢弃的多剂瓶疫苗有时比单剂瓶更少被提供,可能错失接种机会。
核心结论
- 改善报告表格、增加培训和支持性督导可促进更准确地报告所有浪费原因。
- 全球范围内,减少每瓶剂数可降低开瓶浪费。
- 封闭瓶浪费虽相对罕见,但个别情况可造成大量损失,监测封闭瓶浪费不应被忽视。
研究设计与样本
- 在加纳(n=48)、莫桑比克(n=36)和巴基斯坦(n=46)的疫苗接种服务点,对四种疫苗的浪费情况进行评估。
- 使用前瞻性每日和每月疫苗使用数据录入表、横断面调查和深度访谈。
主要发现
- 单剂瓶或开封后可冷藏保存最多四周的多剂瓶疫苗的估计月度比例开瓶浪费率为0.08%至3%。
- 开封后六小时内丢弃剩余剂次的多剂瓶疫苗的平均浪费率为5%至33%,其中含麻疹成分疫苗的浪费率最高。
- 尽管国家层面指南建议即使只有一名儿童也打开疫苗瓶,但开封后六小时内丢弃的多剂瓶疫苗有时比单剂瓶或开封后剩余剂次可使用最多四周的多剂瓶疫苗更少被提供。
- 疫苗接种服务点的封闭瓶浪费相对罕见,但个别情况可造成大量损失。
- 卫生工作者报告对疫苗浪费追踪和报告方法知识不足。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Vaccine procurement costs comprise a significant share of immunization program costs in low- and middle-income countries, yet not all procured vaccines are administered. Vaccine wastage occurs due to vial breakage, excessive heat or freezing, expiration, or when not all doses in a multidose vial are used. Better estimates of vaccine wastage rates and their causes could support improved management of vaccine stocks and reduce procurement costs. This study examined aspects of wastage for four vaccines at service delivery points in Ghana (n = 48), Mozambique (n = 36), and Pakistan (n = 46). We used prospective data from daily and monthly vaccine usage data entry forms, along with cross-sectional surveys, and in-depth interviews. The analysis found that estimated monthly proportional open-vial wastage rates for vaccines in single-dose vials (SDV) or in multi-dose vials (MDV) that can be kept refrigerated up to four weeks after opening ranged from 0.08 % to 3 %. For MDV where remaining doses are discarded within six hours after opening, the mean wastage rates ranged from 5 % to 33 %, with rates being highest for measles containing vaccine. Despite national-level guidance to open a vaccine vial even when only one child is present, vaccines in MDV that are discarded within six hours of opening are sometimes offered less frequently than vaccines in SDV or in MDV where remaining doses can be used for up to 4 weeks. This practice can lead to missed opportunities for vaccination. While closed-vial wastage at service delivery points (SDPs) was relatively rare, individual instances can result in large losses, suggesting that monitoring closed-vial wastage should not be neglected. Health workers reported insufficient knowledge of vaccine wastage tracking and reporting methods. Improving reporting forms would facilitate more accurate reporting of all causes of wastage, as would additional training and supportive supervision. Globally, decreasing doses per vial could reduce open-vial wastage.
引用
- Mvundura M, Ng J, Reynolds K, et al. Vaccine wastage in Ghana, Mozambique, and Pakistan: An assessment of wastage rates for four vaccines and the context, causes, drivers, and knowledge, attitudes and practices for vaccine wastage. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37270365. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.05.033
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。