理解个人经历与情境变量在塑造风险降低偏好中的作用
该研究在智利、哥伦比亚和哥斯达黎加开展选择实验,考察新冠疫情期间风险降低偏好如何受个人经历与情境变量影响。实验属性为风险降低、潜伏期和成本,采用混合logit模型捕捉跨国偏好异质性。结果显示实验属性在各国有统计显著且符号符合预期,亲近性和就业状况表现一致,而严重程度、风险群体和疫苗接种状态结果混合;偏好异质性在实验属性上大于个人经历与情境变量。
要点
- 选择实验属性(风险降低、潜伏期、成本)在三国均统计显著且符号符合预期。
- 亲近性和就业状况在各国的行为表现一致。
- 严重程度、风险群体和疫苗接种状态呈现混合结果。
核心结论
- 风险降低偏好因个体在疫情下面临的日常情境而异,可能造成评估疫情缓解政策所用值的扭曲。
研究设计与样本
- 在智利、哥伦比亚和哥斯达黎加开展选择实验,属性为风险降低、潜伏期和成本,采用混合logit模型捕捉跨国偏好异质性。
主要发现
- 实验属性在各国均统计显著且符号符合预期。
- 亲近性和就业状况在各国表现一致。
- 严重程度、风险群体和疫苗接种状态呈现混合结果。
- 偏好异质性在实验属性上大于个人经历和情境变量。
临床怎么用
- 理解这些变量的影响对制定更有效的风险降低政策至关重要,例如统计生命价值等方法基于社会对风险降低的估值进行计算。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
This article explores how preferences for risk reduction during the COVID-19 pandemic are influenced by personal experiences and contextual variables such as having a close friend or relative who has been infected by the virus (closeness), the severity of the illness (severity), people's own perceptions of being in a risky group (risk group), change in employment status due to the pandemic (employment situation), and vaccination status (vaccination status and altruistic vaccination). We conducted a choice experiment (CE) in Chile, Colombia, and Costa Rica. The attributes of the experiment were risk reduction, latency, and cost. Then, we estimated a mixed logit model to capture preference heterogeneity across the countries. The attributes presented in the CE were statistically significant, with the expected sign in each country. The variables closeness and employment situation presented homogeneous behavior in each country; however, severity, risk group, and vaccination status showed mixed results. We found that preferences were more heterogeneous for the attributes of the CE than for the personal experiences and contextual variables. Understanding the impact of these variables is essential for generating more effective risk reduction policies. For instance, methodologies such as the value of statistical life base their calculations on society's valuation of risk reduction. We provide evidence that the preferences for risk reduction vary due to the everyday situations that individuals face in the context of the pandemic. The latter may cause distortions in the values used to evaluate policies aimed at mitigating the outbreak.
引用
- Barrientos M, Vásquez-Lavin F, Rosales C, et al. Understanding the role of personal experiences and contextual variables in shaping risk reduction preferences. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37258386. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.05.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。