疫苗接种、人群流动与COVID-19健康结局:SARS-CoV-2 B.1.1.529(Omicron)变异株暴发前后的实证比较
本研究利用美国两年多县级COVID-19数据,在控制社会经济、人口、种族/民族与党派因素后,用横断面模型比较Omicron暴发前后的COVID-19健康结局,并用时变中介分析刻画疫苗与流动对结局影响的随时间变化。结果显示,Omicron期间疫苗对病例率的效果失去显著性,对病死率的效果全程显著;流动在各变异株暴发波次均与病例率呈显著正相关,并显著中介疫苗对病例率的作用。
要点
- Omicron暴发期间疫苗对病例率的效果失去显著性,对病死率的效果全程显著。
- 不论疫苗接种率高低,弱势人群始终承担更大的病例与死亡负担。
- 流动在各变异株暴发波次均与病例率呈显著正相关,并显著中介疫苗效果。
核心结论
- Omicron暴发期间疫苗对病例率的效果失去显著性,而针对病死率的效果在整个大流行期间保持显著。
- 仅依赖疫苗接种来阻断COVID-19的做法需要重新审视,作者认为需要资源充足且协调一致的努力来增强疫苗效果、缩小健康差距并有选择地放松非药物干预。
研究设计与样本
- 基于美国两年多县级COVID-19数据的实证比较研究,先拟合一组横断面模型比较Omicron暴发前后的COVID-19健康结局差异,再采用时变中介分析刻画疫苗与流动对健康结局影响随时间的变化。
- 健康结局通过病例率和病死率评估,并控制社会经济、人口、种族/民族与党派因素。
主要发现
- 疫苗对病例率的效果在Omicron暴发期间失去显著性。
- 疫苗对病死率的效果在整个大流行期间保持显著。
- COVID-19相关结局存在显著结构性不平等,弱势人群始终承担更大的病例与死亡负担,且与高疫苗接种率无关。
- 流动在各变异株暴发波次均与病例率呈显著正相关。
- 流动显著中介了疫苗接种对病例率的直接效应,使疫苗效果平均下降10.276%(95%CI:6.257,14.294)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,仅依赖疫苗接种来阻断COVID-19的做法需要重新审视。
- 作者认为,资源充足且协调一致地增强疫苗效果、缩小健康差距并有选择地放松非药物干预,对终结大流行是必要的。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The B.1.1.529 (Omicron) variant surge has raised concerns about the effectiveness of vaccines and the impact of imprudent reopening. Leveraging over two years of county-level COVID-19 data in the US, this study aims to investigate relationships among vaccination, human mobility, and COVID-19 health outcomes (assessed via case rate and case-fatality rate), controlling for socioeconomic, demographic, racial/ethnic, and partisan factors. A set of cross-sectional models was first fitted to empirically compare disparities in COVID-19 health outcomes before and during the Omicron surge. Then, time-varying mediation analyses were employed to delineate how the effects of vaccine and mobility on COVID-19 health outcomes vary over time. Results showed that vaccine effectiveness against case rate lost significance during the Omicron surge, while its effectiveness against case-fatality rate remained significant throughout the pandemic. We also documented salient structural inequalities in COVID-19-related outcomes, with disadvantaged populations consistently bearing a larger brunt of case and death tolls, regardless of high vaccination rates. Last, findings revealed that mobility presented a significantly positive relationship with case rates during each wave of variant outbreak. Mobility substantially mediated the direct effect from vaccination to case rate, leading to a 10.276 % (95 % CI: 6.257, 14.294) decrease in vaccine effectiveness on average. Altogether, our study implies that sole reliance on vaccination to halt COVID-19 needs to be re-examined. Well-resourced and coordinated efforts to enhance vaccine effectiveness, mitigate health disparity and selectively loosen non-pharmaceutical interventions are essential to bringing the pandemic to an end.
引用
- Hu S, Xiong C, Zhao Y, et al. Vaccination, human mobility, and COVID-19 health outcomes: Empirical comparison before and during the outbreak of SARS-Cov-2 B.1.1.529 (Omicron) variant. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37270367. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.05.056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。