用于测量自然感染或疫苗接种后抗体应答动力学的宿主内建模:一项系统综述
该系统综述检索PubMed和Web of Science截至2022年5月的文献,纳入78篇以数学模型测量抗体动力学的合格出版物。其中8篇采用常微分方程(ODEs)建模描述疫苗接种后抗体动力学,12篇将此类模型用于自然感染诱导的体液免疫。结论指出多数研究侧重现象学模型而非机制模型,年龄组等风险因素信息有限及缺乏实验或观察数据是解读建模结果的重要关切。
要点
- 共纳入78篇合格出版物,其中8篇用ODEs建模描述疫苗接种后抗体动力学,12篇用于自然感染体液免疫。
- 机制建模研究按研究类型、样本量、测量指标、抗体半衰期、 compartments与参数、推断或分析方法及模型选择进行汇总。
- 多数研究侧重现象学模型而非机制模型,年龄组或其他可能影响抗体动力学的风险因素信息有限。
核心结论
- 尽管研究抗体动力学及体液免疫(消退)机制很重要,但很少有出版物在数学模型中明确考虑这一点。
- 大多数研究侧重现象学模型而非机制模型。
- 年龄组或其他可能影响抗体动力学的风险因素信息有限,以及缺乏实验或观察数据,仍是解读数学建模结果的重要关切。
- 数据驱动的机制模型往往更简单化,而理论驱动方法缺乏代表性数据来验证模型结果。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索PubMed和Web of Science数据库中截至2022年5月发表的合格文献。
- 合格出版物包括以抗体动力学测量为主要结局的数学模型研究(从现象学模型到机制模型)。
- 共识别78篇合格出版物,其中8篇基于常微分方程(ODEs)建模方法描述疫苗接种后抗体动力学,12篇将此类模型用于自然感染诱导的体液免疫。
主要发现
- 8篇出版物采用基于ODEs的建模方法描述疫苗接种后抗体动力学。
- 12篇研究将此类模型用于自然感染诱导的体液免疫背景。
- 机制建模研究按研究类型、样本量、测量指标、抗体半衰期、 compartments与参数、推断或分析方法及模型选择进行汇总。
- 综述了疫苗接种后与感染后抗体动力学的相似性,强调将一些特征从一种情境转化到另一种情境可能值得。
- 数据驱动的机制模型往往更简单化,理论驱动方法缺乏代表性数据来验证模型结果。
关键数值与推荐
- 合格出版物为以抗体动力学测量为主要结局的数学模型研究,范围从现象学模型到机制模型。
- 共识别78篇合格出版物,其中8篇采用ODEs建模描述疫苗接种后抗体动力学,12篇用于自然感染诱导的体液免疫。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 年龄组或其他可能影响抗体动力学的风险因素信息有限。
- 缺乏实验或观察数据。
- 数据驱动的机制模型往往更简单化。
- 理论驱动方法缺乏代表性数据来验证模型结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Within-host models describe the dynamics of immune cells when encountering a pathogen, and how these dynamics can lead to an individual-specific immune response. This systematic review aims to summarize which within-host methodology has been used to study and quantify antibody kinetics after infection or vaccination. In particular, we focus on data-driven and theory-driven mechanistic models. MATERIALS: PubMed and Web of Science databases were used to identify eligible papers published until May 2022. Eligible publications included those studying mathematical models that measure antibody kinetics as the primary outcome (ranging from phenomenological to mechanistic models). RESULTS: We identified 78 eligible publications, of which 8 relied on an Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs)-based modelling approach to describe antibody kinetics after vaccination, and 12 studies used such models in the context of humoral immunity induced by natural infection. Mechanistic modeling studies were summarized in terms of type of study, sample size, measurements collected, antibody half-life, compartments and parameters included, inferential or analytical method, and model selection. CONCLUSIONS: Despite the importance of investigating antibody kinetics and underlying mechanisms of (waning of) the humoral immunity, few publications explicitly account for this in a mathematical model. In particular, most research focuses on phenomenological rather than mechanistic models. The limited information on the age groups or other risk factors that might impact antibody kinetics, as well as a lack of experimental or observational data remain important concerns regarding the interpretation of mathematical modeling results. We reviewed the similarities between the kinetics following vaccination and infection, emphasising that it may be worth translating some features from one setting to another. However, we also stress that some biological mechanisms need to be distinguished. We found that data-driven mechanistic models tend to be more simplistic, and theory-driven approaches lack representative data to validate model results.
引用
- Garcia-Fogeda I, Besbassi H, Larivière Y, et al. Within-host modeling to measure dynamics of antibody responses after natural infection or vaccination: A systematic review. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37198016. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.04.030
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。