如何减少疫苗接种犹豫?证据及其传播者的相关性
该研究基于德国2145名未接种新冠疫苗受访者的在线调查实验,采用潜在类别分析识别出反对者、怀疑者和原则上可接受者三个亚组。结果显示,平均而言提供统计或轶事证据均未提高信息说服力,但科学家比政治家平均更具说服力;不同亚组对证据类型和传播者的反应存在异质性。
要点
- 未接种者可分为反对者(N=1184)、怀疑者(N=572)和原则上可接受者(N=389)三个亚组。
- 平均而言,提供统计或轶事证据均未增加新冠疫苗有效性信息的说服力。
- 科学家平均比政治家更具说服力,相对提高接种意愿0.184个标准差。
核心结论
- 未接种新冠疫苗个体可依据对疫苗接种的态度分为反对者、怀疑者和原则上可接受者三个亚组,不同亚组对证据类型和传播者的反应存在异质性。
- 平均而言,提供统计或轶事证据均未提高关于新冠疫苗有效性信息的说服力,但科学家比政治家平均更具说服力(相对提高接种意愿0.184个标准差)。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为在德国开展的原创在线调查实验,纳入2145名未接种新冠疫苗的受访者。
- 研究采用潜在类别分析探索未接种个体对新冠疫苗接种态度的亚组特征,并考察不同类型证据(无/轶事/统计)和不同传播者(科学家/政治家)对各亚组接种意愿的影响。
主要发现
- 潜在类别分析识别出三个亚组:反对者(N=1184)、怀疑者(N=572)和原则上可接受者(N=389)。
- 平均而言,提供统计证据或轶事证据均未增加关于新冠疫苗有效性信息的说服力。
- 科学家平均比政治家更具说服力,相对提高接种意愿0.184个标准差。
- 反对者似乎基本无法被触及;怀疑者重视科学家提供的信息,尤其当辅以轶事证据时(相对提高接种意愿0.45个标准差)。
- 原则上可接受者对政治家提供的统计证据反应更强(相对提高接种意愿0.38个标准差)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Even though the immediate urgency of the COVID-19 pandemic seems to have passed, many countries did not reach the vaccination rates they initially aimed for. The stagnation in vaccine uptake during the height of the pandemic presented policy makers with a challenge that remains unresolved and is paramount for future pandemics and other crises: How to convince the (often not insubstantial) unvaccinated proportion of the population of the benefits of a vaccination? Designing more successful communication strategies, both in retrospect and looking ahead, requires a differentiated understanding of the concerns of those that remain unvaccinated. Guided by the elaboration likelihood model, this paper has two objectives: First, it explores by means of a latent class analysis how unvaccinated individuals might be characterized by their attitudes towards COVID-19 vaccination. Second, we investigate to what extent (i) varying types of evidence (none/anecdotal/statistical) can be employed by (ii) different types of communicators (scientists/politicians) to improve vaccination intentions across these subgroups. To address these questions, we conducted an original online survey experiment among 2145 unvaccinated respondents from Germany where a substantial population share remains unvaccinated. The results suggest three different subgroups, which differ regarding their openness towards a COVID-19 vaccination: Vaccination opponents (N = 1184), sceptics (N = 572) and those in principle receptive (N = 389) to be vaccinated. On average, neither the provision of statistical nor anecdotal evidence increased the persuasiveness of information regarding the efficacy of a COVID-19 vaccine. However, scientists were, on average, more persuasive than politicians (relatively increase vaccination intentions by 0.184 standard deviations). With respect to heterogeneous treatment effects among the three subgroups, vaccination opponents seem largely unreachable, while sceptics value information by scientists, particularly if supported by anecdotal evidence (relatively increases intentions by 0.45 standard deviations). Receptives seem much more responsive to statistical evidence from politicians (relatively increases intentions by 0.38 standard deviations).
引用
- Eger J, Kaplan LC, Sternberg H, et al. How to reduce vaccination hesitancy? The relevance of evidence and its communicator. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37221120. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.03.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。