应用理论域框架识别美国男性大学生补种HPV疫苗接种的影响因素:证据综述与建议
该综述检索5个数据库2009年1月至2019年7月的实证研究,纳入17项美国高校18-26岁男性研究,用理论域框架(TDF)分析发现11个影响补种HPV疫苗接种的关键域,障碍包括知识缺乏、无医生推荐、无医保、感知易感性低和疫苗错误信息等,促进因素为感知疫苗获益高。
要点
- 知识域在82%的纳入研究中影响男性大学生HPV疫苗接种行为。
- 障碍包括HPV及疫苗知识缺乏、无医生推荐、无医保和疫苗错误信息。
- 感知HPV疫苗获益高是补种HPV疫苗接种的促进因素。
核心结论
- 研究从理论层面识别了影响美国男性大学生补种HPV疫苗接种的因素,可为高校高风险男性补种干预的规划、支持和实施提供信息。
研究设计与样本
- 综述检索Medline、Embase、CINAHL、ERIC和PsycINFO五个数据库2009年1月至2019年7月的定量与定性实证研究,评估美国高校18-26岁男性HPV疫苗接种情况。
- 最终纳入17项研究进行数据提取,采用混合演绎-归纳法内容分析将数据归类至理论域框架(TDF)的域、主题和亚主题。
主要发现
- 识别出11个影响男性大学生HPV疫苗接种行为的关键TDF域:知识(82%的纳入研究)、环境背景与资源(53%)、对后果的信念(53%)、不切实际的乐观(50%)与悲观(6%)、情绪(50%)、社会影响(50%)、对能力的信念(41%)、意向(24%)、强化(18%)、社会职业角色与认同(12%)和行为调节(12%)。
- 障碍包括:缺乏HPV感染、HPV疫苗安全性、有效性、副作用和费用的知识与意识;缺少卫生服务提供者的推荐;缺乏医疗服务和医疗保险;对HPV感染的感知易感性和严重性水平低;HPV疫苗错误信息;以及关于HPV疫苗接种的社会污名和同伴影响。
- 促进因素包括:对HPV疫苗的感知获益水平高。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,本研究结果可为高校高风险男性补种HPV疫苗接种干预的高效规划、支持和实施提供信息。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Genital human papillomavirus (HPV) infection is the most prevalent sexually transmitted infection among young adults ages 15-25 years in the United States (US). Although HPV vaccines are recommended for individuals ages through 26 years, vaccine completion rates remain substantially low. METHODS: Accordingly, our study utilized a comprehensive - Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) of behavior change to systematically identify facilitators and barriers to catch-up HPV vaccinations. Five databases - Medline, Embase, CINAHL, ERIC, and PsycINFO were searched from January 2009 to July 2019 for empirical studies using quantitative and qualitative methods to assess HPV vaccine uptake among males ages 18-26 years within US college and university settings. The TDF analytic process included a content analysis using the mixed deductive-inductive approach to extract, analyze and categorize data into TDF domains/themes and sub-themes. RESULTS: Overall, 17 studies were selected for data extraction. We identified eleven key TDF domains that influenced HPV vaccination behavior among college male students: 'knowledge' (82% of included studies), 'environmental context and resources' (53%), 'beliefs about consequences' (53%), 'unrealistic optimism' (50%) and 'pessimism' (6%), 'emotion' (50%), 'social influences' (50%), 'beliefs about capabilities' (41%), 'intention' (24%), 'reinforcement' (18%), 'social professional role and identity'(12%), and 'behavioral regulation' (12%). Barriers influencing HPV vaccine uptake included lack of knowledge and awareness regarding HPV infections, HPV vaccine safety, effectiveness, side effects, and costs; absence of health providers' recommendations; lack of healthcare and health insurance; low levels of perceived susceptibility and severity for HPV infections; HPV vaccine misinformation; as well as social stigma and peer influences regarding HPV vaccinations. Enablers for HPV vaccine uptake included high levels of perceived benefits for HPV vaccines. DISCUSSION: Our study theoretically identified factors influencing HPV vaccinations. This could inform the efficient planning, support, and implementation of interventions that facilitate catch-up HPV vaccination practices among high-risk males within college/university settings.
引用
- Olusanya OA, Tomar A, Thomas J, et al. Application of the theoretical domains framework to identify factors influencing catch-up HPV vaccinations among male college students in the United States: A review of evidence and recommendations. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37164820. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.04.071
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。