为支持准确及时的COVID-19疫苗覆盖率估计而随时间实施的方法学变更:加拿大安大略省
加拿大安大略省在多年COVID-19疫苗接种计划中,建立COVaxON电子免疫登记系统并随时间调整方法学以持续评估年龄别疫苗覆盖率。方法学变更使覆盖率估计值得到改善,例如70-79岁人群至少一剂覆盖率从104.9%(方法B)降至95.0%(方法D),所有估计值均不再超过100%。该登记系统对疫苗计划监测具有变革性意义。
要点
- 安大略省建立COVaxON电子COVID-19免疫登记系统,捕获全省所有接种剂次的个体水平数据。
- 随时间实施四种方法学变更(方法A至D),以支持多年疫苗接种计划中持续的年龄别覆盖率评估。
- 方法学变更使覆盖率估计值改善,70-79岁人群至少一剂覆盖率从104.9%(方法B)降至95.0%(方法D),所有估计值均不超过100%。
核心结论
- 方法学变更改善了估计值,使覆盖率估计值均不超过100%。
- 安大略省COVID-19免疫登记系统对疫苗计划监测具有变革性意义,单一登记系统的实施对于全面近实时覆盖率评估至关重要。
- 该省有能力在COVID-19大流行所取得的成果基础上,将登记系统扩展至其他常规疫苗接种计划。
研究设计与样本
- 本文描述了安大略省COVID-19免疫登记系统(COVaxON)、随时间实施的用于持续评估年龄别疫苗覆盖率的方法,以及这些方法学变更的影响。
- 疫苗接种数据(分子)从COVaxON获取,用于计算年龄别覆盖率估计值。
主要发现
- 整个疫苗接种计划期间使用了四种不同的方法学方法计算年龄别覆盖率估计值。
- 年龄别分子最初使用首次接种时的年龄计算(方法A),后更新为覆盖率评估时的年龄(方法B)。
- 数据库增强允许从分子中排除已故个体(方法C)。
- 人口数据(分母)在2021年全国人口普查的2022年预测数据可用后进行了更新(方法D)。
- 方法学变更的影响在疫苗 uptake 高的老年年龄组最为明显,例如70-79岁人群至少一剂覆盖率从104.9%(方法B)降至95.0%(方法D)。
关键数值与推荐
- 方法A:年龄别分子使用首次接种时的年龄计算。
- 方法B:年龄别分子更新为覆盖率评估时的年龄。
- 方法C:从分子中排除已故个体。
- 方法D:分母更新为2021年全国人口普查的2022年预测数据。
- 70-79岁人群至少一剂覆盖率:方法B为104.9%,方法D为95.0%。
临床怎么用
- 安大略省COVID-19免疫登记系统已对疫苗计划监测产生变革性影响。
- 单一COVID-19疫苗登记系统的实施对于全面近实时覆盖率评估至关重要,并使数据的新用途成为可能,以支持疫苗计划监测的其他组成部分。
- 该省有能力在COVID-19大流行所取得的成果基础上,将登记系统扩展至其他常规疫苗接种计划。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The COVID-19 vaccination program implementation in Ontario, Canada has spanned multiple years and is ongoing. To meet the challenges of the program, Ontario developed and implemented a new electronic COVID-19 immunization registry, COVaxON, which captures individual-level data on all doses administered in the province enabling comprehensive coverage assessment. However, the need for ongoing COVID-19 vaccine coverage assessments over a multi-year vaccination program posed challenges necessitating methodological changes. This paper describes Ontario's COVID-19 immunization registry, the methods implemented over time to allow for the ongoing assessment of vaccine coverage by age, and the impact of those methodological changes. Throughout the course of the vaccination program, four different methodological approaches were used to calculate age-specific coverage estimates using vaccination data (numerator) obtained from COVaxON. Age-specific numerators were initially calculated using age at time of first dose (method A), but were updated to the age at coverage assessment (method B). Database enhancements allowed for the exclusion of deceased individuals from the numerator (method C). Population data (denominator) was updated to 2022 projections from the 2021 national census following their availability (method D). The impact was most evident in older age groups where vaccine uptake was high. For example, coverage estimates for individuals aged 70-79 years of age for at least one dose decreased from 104.9 % (method B) to 95.0 % (method D). Thus, methodological changes improved estimates such that none exceeded 100 %. Ontario's COVID-19 immunization registry has been transformational for vaccine program surveillance. The implementation of a single registry for COVID-19 vaccines was essential for comprehensive near real-time coverage assessment, and enabled new uses of the data to support additional components of vaccine program surveillance. The province is well positioned to build on what has been achieved as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic and expand the registry to other routine vaccination programs.
引用
- Leigh Hobbs J, Paul LA, Buchan SA, et al. Methodological changes implemented over time to support accurate and timely COVID-19 vaccine coverage estimates: Ontario, Canada. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37087395. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.04.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。