新冠大流行期间关于疫苗的公共话语与辩论:对Twitter的定性内容分析
该研究对含「疫苗」及其派生词的英文Twitter帖子样本进行人工内容分析,归类7个内容变量及发布者类型和转发数。结果发现,负面语气推文中33%为否定主义话语、29%为抗议或挑衅话语、13%讨论大流行管理措施、另13%呈现科学话语;预防性信息平均转发更多,媒体和记者账号转发最多。
要点
- 负面语气推文中33%为否定主义、29%为抗议或挑衅、13%讨论大流行管理措施、13%为科学话语。
- 研究结果、疫苗接种数据和实用信息更多与正面语气相关,新闻更多与中性语气相关。
- 媒体账号和记者获得最多转发,其次是与政府相关的政府账号和科学组织;预防性信息平均转发更多。
核心结论
- 尽管存在不可忽视的直接反对疫苗的推文,但相当部分疫苗负面内容以抗议话语、对政府行动及大流行应对措施的批评形式出现。
- 大流行期间的负面话语包含严重的疫苗犹豫案例,且不仅由对科学的不信任驱动,还与对公共卫生管理的不满密切相关。
研究设计与样本
- 对含「疫苗」及其派生词的英文Twitter帖子样本进行人工内容分析,归类7个内容变量,并分类发布者类型和转发数,进一步探索变量间的关联模式。
主要发现
- 负面语气推文中,33%展示否定主义话语,29%为抗议或挑衅话语,13%讨论大流行管理措施,另13%展示科学话语。
- 研究结果、疫苗接种数据和实用信息更多与对疫苗的正面语气相关,新闻更多与中性语气相关。
- 获得最多转发的用户是媒体账号和记者,其次是与政府相关的政府账号和科学组织;展示预防性信息的推文平均获得更多转发。
- 与客观信息最相关的话语是预防性、机构性、医学科学以及关于不同大流行管理措施的话语;最主观的推文是否定主义、反否定主义和抗议话语。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: Characterize the public debate and discourse about vaccines during the covid-19 vaccination programmes. METHODS: We performed a manual content analysis of a sample of English-written Twitter posts that included the word vaccine and its derivatives. We categorized 7 variables pertaining to the content of the posts, and classified the type of user that published the post and the number of retweets. Then, the patterns of association between these variables were further explored. RESULTS: Among the tweets with negative tone towards vaccines, 33% display negationist discourses, 29% protest or defiance discourses, 13% discuss the pandemic management measures and yet another 13% of these tweets display a scientific discourse. Research results, vaccination data and practical information are more associated to positive tone towards vaccines, while news relate to neutral tone. The users that received more retweets were media accounts and journalists, followed by government accounts and scientific organizations related to the government. Tweets displaying preventive messages received more retweets in average. The discourses most associated with objective information are the preventive, institutional, medical-scientific, and those about the different measures to manage the pandemic. On the other hand, the most subjective tweets are those with negationist, antinegationist and protest discourses. CONCLUSIONS: Although there is a non-negligible proportion of tweets that are directly opposed to vaccines, also an important part of vaccine-negative content takes the form of protest discourses, criticisms towards government actions as well as towards the measures to tackle the pandemic. Therefore, negative discourses during the pandemic included serious vaccine hesitancy cases. Moreover, they were not only fuelled by distrust in science, but also and very importantly they were connected to dissatisfaction towards the public management of the pandemic.
引用
- Prada E, Langbecker A, Catalan-Matamoros D, et al. Public discourse and debate about vaccines in the midst of the covid-19 pandemic: A qualitative content analysis of Twitter. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 37080830. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.03.068
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。