错误的共识:关于医生观点的错误信念如何影响新冠疫苗犹豫
研究基于美国成年人代表性调查(N=5482)和初级保健医生(PCP)子样本(N=625),比较美国人与PCP对防控新冠行动责任归属的偏好,以及美国人对PCP偏好的感知(PCP元观点)。多数美国人认为PCP与自己观点一致(τb=0.44-0.49),但这种一致性常是错误的;多变量模型提示,既认为个人责任作用小又认为PCP持相同看法的美国人显著更不可能接种新冠疫苗。
要点
- 美国人比PCP更不倾向于认为私人和国家行为者在防控新冠中应发挥作用。
- 多数美国人认为PCP与自己关于国家和私人干预的观点一致(τb=0.44-0.49),但此一致性常是错误的。
- 认为个人责任作用小且认为PCP持相同看法者显著更不可能接种新冠疫苗。
核心结论
- 美国人总体比PCP更不认可私人和国家行为者在防控新冠中的作用,且个体层面感知的PCP观点常错误地与自身一致,这种错误共识与更低的疫苗接种可能性相关。
研究设计与样本
- 采用新颖的人口学代表性美国成年人调查(N=5482)和初级保健医生子样本(PCPs;N=625),比较美国人与PCP对防控新冠行动责任归属的偏好及美国人对PCP偏好的感知。
主要发现
- 总体上,美国人远比PCP更不倾向于认为私人和国家行为者在防控新冠中应发挥作用。
- 个体层面,多数美国人认为PCP与自己关于国家和私人干预的观点一致(τb=0.44-0.49)。
- 多变量模型提示,既认为个人责任在阻止病毒传播中作用小又认为PCP持相同看法的美国人显著更不可能接种新冠疫苗。
关键数值与推荐
- 美国成年人调查N=5482,PCP子样本N=625。
- 美国人与PCP元观点一致性τb=0.44-0.49。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出临床推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, researchers have studied how Americans' attitudes toward health experts influence their health behaviors and policy opinions. Fewer, however, consider the potential gap between individual and expert opinion about COVID-19, and how that might shape health attitudes and behavior. This omission is notable, as discrepancies between individual and expert opinion could help explain why some Americans fail to take action to protect themselves and others from the virus. In novel demographically representative surveys of the US adult population (N = 5,482) and primary care physician subpopulations (PCPs; N = 625), we contrast the relationship between: (1) Americans' and (2) PCPs' preferences regarding who ought to be responsible for taking action to combat the spread of COVID-19, as well as (3) Americans' perceptions of PCP preferences ("PCP meta-opinion"). In the aggregate, we find that Americans are far less likely than PCPs to see a role for both private and state actors in taking action to combat COVID-19. Interestingly, though, this disjuncture is not reflected in individual-level PCP meta-opinion; as most Americans think that PCPs share their views on state and private intervention (τb = 0.44-0.49). However, this consonance is often erroneous, which we show can have problematic health consequences. Multivariate models suggest that Americans who both see little place for individual responsibility in taking action to stop viral spread and who think that PCPs share those views are significantly less likely to vaccinate against COVID-19. We conclude by discussing the public health benefits of efforts to bring public opinion in line with expert opinion.
引用
- Motta M, Callaghan T, Lunz-Trujillo K, et al. Erroneous Consonance. How inaccurate beliefs about physician opinion influence COVID-19 vaccine hesitancy. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 36822967. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.02.052
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。