成败在此一举:新冠疫情时期的按时接种疫苗意愿
本研究基于2020年4月疫情早期对六个欧洲国家民众的新冠疫苗接种偏好调查,检验接种成功取决于两方面:一是超越健康问题的更广泛风险感知因素,二是接种运动启动时足够的社会与机构信任。研究发现,解决这两个障碍维度可使新冠疫苗接种覆盖率进一步提升22%。
要点
- 解决风险感知与信任两个障碍维度可使新冠疫苗接种覆盖率提升22%。
- 拒绝接种者更担心家庭紧张与经济状况,而非健康问题。
- 犹豫接种者是媒体与政府行动提升透明度的主要目标人群。
核心结论
- 除传统因素外,疫苗接种成功取决于应对更广泛风险感知因素和确保足够社会与机构信任两个维度,解决这两个障碍可使覆盖率提升22%。
研究设计与样本
- 基于2020年4月疫情早期对六个欧洲国家民众新冠疫苗接种偏好的调查,采用监督式非参数机器学习技术(随机森林)检验假设,并明确调整调查应答以考虑可能的报告偏倚。
主要发现
- 解决两个障碍维度可使新冠疫苗接种覆盖率进一步提升22%。
- 拒绝接种者相比健康问题更担心家庭紧张与财务状况(假设维度1)。
- 犹豫接种者是媒体与政府行动提升透明度的战场(假设维度2)。
- 随机森林方法捕捉到风险与信任变量间的高阶交互作用,强烈预测按时接种意愿。
- 疫苗犹豫公民可能低报其接种意愿。
局限性
- 疫苗犹豫公民可能低报其接种意愿。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
On-time effective vaccination is critical to curbing a pandemic, but this is often hampered by citizens' hesitancy to get quickly vaccinated. This research concentrates on the hypothesis that, besides traditional factors in the literature, vaccination success would hinge on two dimensions: a) addressing a broader set of risk perception factors than health-related issues only, and b) securing sufficient social and institutional trust at the time of vaccination campaign launch. We test this hypothesis regarding Covid-19 vaccination preferences in six European countries and at the early stage of the pandemic by April 2020. We find that addressing the two roadblock dimensions could further boost Covid-19 vaccination coverage by 22%. The study also offers three extra innovations. The first is that the traditional segmentation logic between vaccine "acceptors", "hesitants" and "refusers" is further justified by the fact that segments have different attitudes: refusers care less about health issues than they are worried about family tensions and finance (dimension 1 of our hypothesis). In contrast, hesitants are the battlefield for more transparency by media and government actions (dimension 2 of our hypothesis). The second added value is that we extend our hypothesis testing with a supervised non-parametric machine learning technique (Random Forests). Again, consistent with our hypothesis, this method picks up higher-order interaction between risk and trust variables that strongly predict on-time vaccination intent. We finally explicitly adjust survey responses to account for possible reporting bias. Among others, vaccine-reluctant citizens may under-report their limited will to get vaccinated.
引用
- Bughin J, Cincera M, Peters K, et al. Make it or break it: On-time vaccination intent at the time of Covid-19. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 36803893. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2023.02.014
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。