新冠疫情开始以来公共卫生权力的司法审查:趋势与启示
文章梳理美国新冠疫情期间各级政府运用法律权力实施关停企业、限制聚集、要求戴口罩和强制接种等措施引发的逾1000件司法判决。常见诉求涉及程序与实质性正当程序、宗教自由及官员权限。超过四分之三的判决中法院拒绝给予原告所寻求的救济,但原告在若干重要案件特别是联邦法院案件中获胜。
要点
- 美国疫情期间公共卫生措施引发逾1000件司法判决。
- 逾四分之三判决中法院拒绝给予原告诉求的救济。
- 原告在若干重要案件尤其是联邦法院案件中获胜。
核心结论
- 美国新冠疫情以来的司法判决及疫情前趋势对公共卫生官员行使权力具有重要启示,尤其当行使涉及宗教自由时。
- 在此法律环境下,官员可能需更多依靠说服力而非仅法律权威。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为法律与公共卫生政策分析,梳理美国新冠疫情期间公共卫生措施引发的逾1000件司法判决及相关趋势。
主要发现
- 疫情期间美国各级政府运用法律权力实施关停企业、限制聚集规模、要求戴口罩和强制接种疫苗等措施。
- 相关命令与规章在诉讼中产生逾1000件司法判决。
- 常见诉求基于程序与实质性正当程序受侵犯、宗教自由受侵犯及官员权限越界。
- 逾四分之三的判决中法院拒绝给予原告所寻求的救济。
- 原告在若干重要案件中获胜,尤其在联邦法院。
临床怎么用
- 作者指出,在此法律环境下官员可能需更多依靠说服力而非仅法律权威。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
During the COVID-19 pandemic, officials in the United States at all levels of government utilized their legal authorities to impose a wide range of measures designed to control the spread of SARS-CoV-2 (severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2; the causative agent of COVID-19), including shutting down businesses, limiting the size of gatherings, requiring masking, and mandating vaccination. These orders and regulations were challenged in court cases that resulted in more than 1000 judicial decisions. Common claims were based on alleged procedural and substantive due process violations, violations of religious liberty, and violations of officials' scope of authority. In more than three fourths of the decisions, the court refused to grant the plaintiffs the relief sought. However, plaintiffs found success in several notable cases, especially in federal court. These recent decisions, as well as broader prepandemic trends, have important implications for public health officials' exercise of their public health powers, especially when those exercises implicate religious liberty. In this legal environment, officials may need to rely more on the powers of persuasion than on their legal authority alone. (Am J Public Health. 2023;113(3):280-287. https://doi.org/10.2105/10.2105/AJPH.2022.307181).
引用
- Parmet WE, Khalik F. Judicial Review of Public Health Powers Since the Start of the COVID-19 Pandemic: Trends and Implications. Am J Public Health. 2023. PMID: 36657096. doi:10.2105/AJPH.2022.307181
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。