文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

应对疫苗错误信息的传播干预措施系统综述

A systematic review of communication interventions for countering vaccine misinformation.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2023-01-09

该系统综述检索多个数据库,纳入34项研究(其中29项评估效果,含25项随机对照试验和4项前后对照研究),识别出9类传播干预策略。吓唬策略和绝对确定的沟通方式可能无效甚至适得其反,而传达证据权重、科学共识、使用幽默和纳入错误信息警告等策略具有前景。

要点

  • 吓唬策略似乎无效,且可能增加对错误信息的认同。
  • 传达确定性而非承认不确定性会适得其反。
  • 有前景的策略包括传达证据权重、科学共识、使用幽默和错误信息警告。

核心结论

  • 该综述识别出一些有前景的应对疫苗错误信息的传播策略。
  • 干预措施应进一步评估对疫苗接种率的影响,而非知识、态度等远端结局,并在准实验和真实情境中开展。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索CINAHL、Web of Science、Scopus、MEDLINE、Embase、PsycInfo和MedRxiv于2021年3月。
  • 共识别2000条记录,34项符合条件的研究涉及目标1,其中29项也涉及目标2(25项随机对照试验和4项前后对照研究)。
  • 针对目标2的试验使用Cochrane随机试验偏倚风险工具(RoB2)评估偏倚风险。

主要发现

  • 识别出9种干预方法,多数聚焦于干预或信息内容(揭穿/纠正、信息性、使用疾病图像或其他吓唬策略、使用幽默、信息强度、纳入错误信息警告、传达证据权重),两种聚焦于干预或信息的传递(时机和来源)。
  • 吓唬策略似乎无效,且可能增加对错误信息的认同。
  • 传达确定性而非承认疫苗效力或风险的不确定性也被发现会适得其反。
  • 有前景的方法包括传达关于疫苗及相关谣言的证据权重和科学共识、使用幽默以及纳入遇到错误信息的警告。
  • 试图揭穿错误信息、信息性方法和传达不确定性结果不一。

关键数值与推荐

  • 吓唬策略似乎无效,且可能增加对错误信息的认同。
  • 传达确定性而非承认不确定性会适得其反。
  • 有前景的方法包括传达证据权重和科学共识、使用幽默和纳入错误信息警告。
  • 揭穿错误信息、信息性方法和传达不确定性结果不一。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Misinformation and disinformation around vaccines has grown in recent years, exacerbated during the Covid-19 pandemic. Effective strategies for countering vaccine misinformation and disinformation are crucial for tackling vaccine hesitancy. We conducted a systematic review to identify and describe communications-based strategies used to prevent and ameliorate the effect of mis- and dis-information on people's attitudes and behaviours surrounding vaccination (objective 1) and examined their effectiveness (objective 2). METHODS: We searched CINAHL, Web of Science, Scopus, MEDLINE, Embase, PsycInfo and MedRxiv in March 2021. The search strategy was built around three themes(1) communications and media; (2) misinformation; and (3) vaccines. For trials addressing objective 2, risk of bias was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias in randomized trials tool (RoB2). RESULTS: Of 2000 identified records, 34 eligible studies addressed objective 1, 29 of which also addressed objective 2 (25 RCTs and 4 before-and-after studies). Nine 'intervention approaches' were identified; most focused on content of the intervention or message (debunking/correctional, informational, use of disease images or other 'scare tactics', use of humour, message intensity, inclusion of misinformation warnings, and communicating weight of evidence), while two focused on delivery of the intervention or message (timing and source). Some strategies, such as scare tactics, appear to be ineffective and may increase misinformation endorsement. Communicating with certainty, rather than acknowledging uncertainty around vaccine efficacy or risks, was also found to backfire. Promising approaches include communicating the weight-of-evidence and scientific consensus around vaccines and related myths, using humour and incorporating warnings about encountering misinformation. Trying to debunk misinformation, informational approaches, and communicating uncertainty had mixed results. CONCLUSION: This review identifies some promising communication strategies for addressing vaccine misinformation. Interventions should be further evaluated by measuring effects on vaccine uptake, rather than distal outcomes such as knowledge and attitudes, in quasi-experimental and real-life contexts.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Whitehead HS, French CE, Caldwell DM, et al. A systematic review of communication interventions for countering vaccine misinformation. Vaccine. 2023. PMID: 36628653. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.12.059

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。