通过诱导比较性思维减少新冠疫苗犹豫
该随机研究在亚马逊机械土耳其和Prolific平台开展,比较「比较性探询」与「审慎性探询」两种疫苗接种邀约方式对疫苗犹豫的影响,并控制政治党派倾向。逻辑回归(N=1736)显示,比较性探询较典型审慎性探询使疫苗犹豫降低6%,在亲特朗普共和党人中平均降低近10%。作者认为这种框架微调可在不增加心理负担、不限制选择自由的情况下减少疫苗犹豫。
要点
- 比较性探询较审慎性探询使疫苗犹豫降低6%(N=1736)。
- 在亲特朗普共和党人中,比较性探询平均降低疫苗犹豫近10%。
- 作者认为该助推在高度疫苗犹豫人群中尤其有效。
核心结论
- 微妙改变疫苗接种邀约的框架,即让人比较选择哪种疫苗而非审慎考虑是否愿意接种,可减少疫苗犹豫,且不造成心理负担或不限制个人选择自由。
- 该助推在亲特朗普共和党人等高度疫苗犹豫人群中尤其有效。
研究设计与样本
- 在亚马逊机械土耳其和Prolific平台上开展的随机研究,通过改变疫苗接种邀约的提问方式分组。
- 一组被问及比较愿意接种哪种疫苗(比较性探询),另一组被问及审慎考虑是否愿意接种疫苗(审慎性探询),同时测量参与者的政治偏好。
- 主要结局变量为疫苗犹豫,采用逻辑回归(N=1736)检验研究问题。
主要发现
- 逻辑回归(N=1736)显示,比较性探询较典型审慎性探询使疫苗犹豫降低6%。
- 疫苗犹豫因个人政治观点而异,但比较性探询即使在最疫苗犹豫人群(亲特朗普共和党人)中平均降低疫苗犹豫近10%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate if a behavioral nudge comprising a vaccination opportunity that employs a comparative probe first (i.e., which vaccine to take) versus the more commonly-used deliberative probe (i.e., willingness to take a vaccine), reduces vaccine hesitancy, while controlling for political partisanship. METHODS: In a randomized study, conducted on Amazon Mechanical Turk and Prolific, we varied the manner in which the vaccination offer is posed. In one group, participants were asked to compare which vaccine they would like to take (i.e., the comparative probe), while, in another group, participants were asked to deliberate whether they would like to take the vaccine (i.e., the deliberative probe). Participants' political preferences were also measured. The primary outcome variable was vaccine hesitancy. RESULTS: A LOGIT regression (N = 1736), was conducted to test the research questions. Overall, the comparative probe yielded a 6% reduction in vaccine hesitancy relative to the typical deliberative probe. Additionally, while vaccine hesitancy varies due to individual political views, the comparative probe is effective at reducing vaccine hesitancy even among the most vaccine hesitant population (i.e., Pro-Trump Republicans) by almost 10% on average. CONCLUSIONS: Subtly changing the manner in which the vaccination offer is framed, by asking people to compare which vaccine to take, and not deliberate about whether they would like to take a vaccine, can reduce vaccine hesitancy, without being psychologically taxing or curtailing individuals' freedom to choose. The nudge is especially effective among highly vaccine hesitant populations such as Pro-Trump Republicans. Our results suggest a costless communication protocol in face-to-face interactions on doorsteps, in clinics, in Pro-Trump regions and in the mass media, that might protect 5 million Americans from COVID-19.
引用
- Hao XB, Anand M, Wang TR, et al. Reducing COVID vaccine hesitancy by inducing a comparative mindset. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 36357289. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.10.077
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。