整合疫苗强制接种的研究议程
本文为一期关于强制疫苗接种的专刊导言,利用拉斯韦尔政策循环启发式综合专刊文章发现,涉及强制接种作为政策选项的出现、公众支持与政策工具设计、实施要点及评估学习,并按研究方面与方法分类文章以形成未来研究者指南。
要点
- 强制接种作为政策选项出现、公众支持与政策工具设计是专刊关注重点。
- 实施要点与对强制接种的评估是专刊综合的主要发现领域。
- 专刊按研究所涉强制接种方面与方法分类,为未来研究者提供指南。
核心结论
- 本专刊可作为整合这一跨学科研究议程的路线图,并为决策者提供有用资源。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为专刊导言,采用拉斯韦尔(1956)政策循环启发式综合专刊文章发现。
主要发现
- 综合发现涉及强制接种作为政策选项的出现、公众支持与政策工具设计、实施要点及从评估中可学习的内容。
- 学者研究推测性或现行强制接种,研究可涉及政策循环多个阶段或仅一个阶段,从态度研究到实施研究与影响研究。
- 对特定强制接种进行深入探讨的历史与情境研究是研究新兴强制接种的急需资源。
- 范围界定与框架构建工作对理解和认识该领域知识生产将无疑有价值。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
A workshop on mandatory vaccination was pitched to the World Public Health Congress in 2019 and the resultant special issue was pitched to Vaccine in 2020. During this project, the COVID-19 pandemic pushed vaccine policy to the forefront of global public health policy, and the imposition of vaccine mandates prompted a new wave of scholarship in the field. This introductory article employs the heuristic of Lasswell's (1956) policy cycle to synthesise the findings of the articles in the special issue. It considers the temporal lifetime of mandates and highlights findings regarding: the emergence of mandates as a policy option, public support and policy instrument design, what matters in the implementation of mandates, and what we can learn from evaluating them. The second half of the paper categorizes the included papers in terms of what aspects of mandates they study and the methods they employ to do so, in order to formulate a guide for future researchers of vaccine mandates. Scholars study either speculative or existing mandates - research can address several stages of the policy cycle or just one of them, ranging from attitudinal research to implementation studies and impact studies. Historical and contextual studies that take deep dives into a particular mandate are a much needed resource for studying emerging mandates, too, and scoping and framework- building work will undoubtedly be valuable in understanding and appreciating the wealth of knowledge production in this growing field. This special issue can serve as a roadmap for a consolidation of this interdisciplinary research agenda, and provide a helpful resource for decisionmakers at this historical juncture.
引用
- Attwell K, Rizzi M, Paul KT, et al. Consolidating a research agenda for vaccine mandates. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 36396514. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.11.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。