文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进传染病防控与疫情报告

纽约市疫苗接种证明要求、激励付款和雇主强制令对COVID-19疫苗接种率的影响:一项合成对照分析

The effect of a proof-of-vaccination requirement, incentive payments, and employer-based mandates on COVID-19 vaccination rates in New York City: a synthetic-control analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Public Health · 2022-01-01

该研究采用合成对照法,比较纽约市与由美国核心大都市区其他县构成的合成对照组在2021年7月26日至11月1日期间的成人疫苗接种率变化。结果显示,纽约市累计成人接种率增加16.9个百分点,而合成对照组增加10.7个百分点,差异为6.2个百分点(95%CI 1.4-10.7),相当于410,201人(90,966-706,532)。作者认为疫苗接种证明要求、激励付款和疫苗强制令的组合提高了纽约市成人接种率。

要点

  • 纽约市累计成人接种率从72.5%升至89.4%(+16.9个百分点),合成对照组从72.5%升至83.2%(+10.7个百分点)。
  • 两组差异为6.2个百分点(95%CI 1.4-10.7),相当于410,201人(90,966-706,532)。
  • 干预开始后不久,纽约市每日疫苗接种量持续高于合成对照组。

核心结论

  • 疫苗接种证明要求、激励付款和疫苗强制令的组合与纽约市成人接种率相对于未采用相同措施的辖区有所提高相关。
  • 无论这些措施是通过诱导更多人接种还是加速了本会稍后发生的接种,接种率的增加可能避免了疾病和死亡。

研究设计与样本

  • 本研究为合成对照分析,构建了由美国核心大都市区其他县组成的纽约市合成对照组。
  • 比较2021年7月26日至11月1日期间纽约市与合成对照组的疫苗接种结局。
  • 分析基于美国疾病控制与预防中心报告的县级疫苗接种数据。
  • 合成对照组通过匹配县级干预前疫苗接种结局、党派倾向、经济属性、人口学和都市区人口构建。
  • 统计推断采用对未处理县的安慰剂检验。

主要发现

  • 合成对照组在匹配过程中使用的属性上与纽约市相似。
  • 纽约市累计成人接种率(18岁及以上至少接种一剂授权COVID-19疫苗的成人)从72.5%升至89.4%(+16.9个百分点)。
  • 合成对照组累计成人接种率从72.5%升至83.2%(+10.7个百分点)。
  • 两组差异为6.2个百分点(95%CI 1.4-10.7),相当于410,201人(90,966-706,532)。
  • 纽约市每日疫苗接种量持续高于合成对照组,该模式在干预期开始后不久出现。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: COVID-19 vaccines have been available to all adults in the USA since April, 2021, but many adults remain unvaccinated. We aimed to assess the joint effect of a proof-of-vaccination requirement, incentive payments, and employer-based mandates on rates of adult vaccination in New York City (NYC). METHODS: We constructed a synthetic control group for NYC composed of other counties in the core of large, metropolitan areas in the USA. The vaccination outcomes for NYC were compared against those of the synthetic control group from July 26, 2021, to Nov 1, 2021, to determine the differential effects of the policies. Analyses were conducted on county-level vaccination data reported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. The synthetic control group was constructed by matching on county-level preintervention vaccination outcomes, partisanship, economic attributes, demographics, and metropolitan area population. Statistical inference was conducted using placebo tests for non-treated counties. FINDINGS: The synthetic control group resembled NYC across attributes used in the matching process. The cumulative adult vaccination rate for NYC (in adults aged 18 years or older who received at least one dose of an authorised COVID-19 vaccine) increased from 72·5% to 89·4% (+16·9 percentage points [pp]) during the intervention period, compared with an increase from 72·5% to 83·2% (+10·7 pp) for the synthetic control group, a difference of 6·2 pp (95% CI 1·4-10·7), or 410 201 people (90 966-706 532). Daily vaccinations for NYC were consistently higher than those in the synthetic control group, a pattern that started shortly after the start of the intervention period. INTERPRETATION: The combination of a proof-of-vaccination requirement, incentive payments, and vaccine mandates increased vaccination rates among adults in NYC compared with jurisdictions that did not use the same measures. Whether the impact of these measures occurred by inducing more people to get vaccinated, or by accelerating vaccinations that would have occurred later, the increase in vaccination rates likely averted illness and death. FUNDING: None.

来源:Lancet Public Health,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cohn E, Chimowitz M, Long T, et al. The effect of a proof-of-vaccination requirement, incentive payments, and employer-based mandates on COVID-19 vaccination rates in New York City: a synthetic-control analysis. Lancet Public Health. 2022. PMID: 36057274. doi:10.1016/S2468-2667(22)00196-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。