患者在接受临床环境中的社会照护干预时的接受障碍
该研究在美国罗德岛一家社区健康中心通过电话访谈26名社会风险筛查阳性的患者,并对诊所工作人员和社区咨询委员会成员开展焦点小组访谈,采用开放编码框架分析访谈转录文本,识别出患者拒绝社会援助的六大主题,涉及筛查问题措辞、文书负担、资源有限经验、羞耻/自尊、污名/歧视及恐惧/不信任等因素。
要点
- 筛查问题措辞、大量文书工作和诊所时间限制可导致不准确报告
- 患者既往求助未获帮助的经历影响其对资源有限性的认知
- 羞耻/自尊、污名/歧视、信念与理解不足、恐惧/不信任均为障碍
核心结论
- 患者接受社会需求支持服务的障碍受健康中心内外多重因素影响,这些发现可为临床环境中社会风险筛查流程的最佳实践和可靠性提供参考,以促进社会正义并确保健康公平。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,2020年至2021年在美国罗德岛一家社区健康中心进行,电话访谈26名社会风险筛查阳性的患者,并对诊所工作人员和社区咨询委员会成员开展Zoom焦点小组访谈,访谈录音转录后由4名研究者采用开放编码框架分析以识别主题。
主要发现
- 数据分析中涌现出6个与患者拒绝社会援助相关的主要主题,这些主题在访谈和不同研究人群中均被识别。
- 参与者解释筛查问题的措辞、大量文书工作和诊所时间限制有时导致不准确报告。
- 患者既往请求社会支持但未获得帮助的经历使其知晓资源有限。
- 羞耻/自尊、污名/歧视、信念与理解不足以及恐惧/不信任也被描述。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Despite efforts to identify and address the social needs of patients in U.S. healthcare settings, researchers consistently find high rates of patients who decline social interventions after reporting that they have unmet social needs. It is an open question as to why people who screen positive for social risks decline assistance. This question was qualitatively explored in a community health center in Rhode Island. METHODS: From 2020 to 2021, a total of 26 patients with a positive screen for social risks were telephonically interviewed. Zoom focus groups with clinic staff and Community Advisory Board members were also conducted. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed. Transcripts were read and analyzed by 4 investigators using an open-coding framework to identify themes emerging from the data and across interviews. RESULTS: A total of 6 dominant themes related to why patients decline social assistance emerged from the data and were identified across interviews and study populations. Participants explained that the wording of screening questions, along with voluminous paperwork and time constraints of the clinic sometimes resulted in inaccurate reporting. Patients' knowledge of limited resources from previous experiences of requesting social support but not receiving help was a theme. Shame/pride, stigma/discrimination, beliefs and lack of understanding, and fear/mistrust were also described. CONCLUSIONS: Barriers to patients' acceptance of services to support social needs were influenced by multiple factors, both internal and external to the health center. These findings can inform best practices related to and the reliability of social risk screening processes in clinic settings to promote social justice and ensure health equity.
引用
- Pfeiffer EJ, De Paula CL, Flores WO, et al. Barriers to Patients' Acceptance of Social Care Interventions in Clinic Settings. Am J Prev Med. 2022. PMID: 35987523. doi:10.1016/j.amepre.2022.03.035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。