通过医学专家背书对抗疫苗犹豫
在意大利开展预注册纵向实验,对2277人沿疫苗接种活动关键阶段监测,比较医学研究者背书与普通他人背书的辟谣信息效果。结果未发现接种行为增加,但实验组接种意愿更高、对疫苗保护性的信念更积极;收到辟谣信息越多,实验组接种意愿提升越大,且效应不受对科学信任度影响。
要点
- 医学研究者背书的辟谣信息未增加实际接种行为,但提高了接种意愿和对疫苗保护性的积极信念。
- 参与者收到的辟谣信息越多,实验组较对照组的接种意愿提升越大,提示多次暴露对专家背书辟谣信息的效果至关重要。
- 上述效应无论参与者对科学的信任程度如何均显著。
核心结论
- 科学家和医学专家不仅是普遍可信的群体,也是在疫苗接种活动中对抗虚假信息的合适信使。
研究设计与样本
- 预注册实验,在意大利沿疫苗接种活动关键阶段开展纵向研究,监测2277人的样本。
- 参与者接受由医学研究者背书(实验组)或由普通他人背书(对照组)的一系列信息。
- 为最小化需求效应,参与者的回应始终在最后一条辟谣信息后十天收集。
主要发现
- 未发现接种行为增加。
- 实验组参与者表现出更高的接种意愿,以及对疫苗保护性更积极的信念。
- 参与者收到的辟谣信息越多,实验组较对照组的接种意愿提升越大。
- 这些效应无论参与者对科学的信任程度如何均显著。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论认为科学家和医学专家是在疫苗接种活动中对抗虚假信息的合适信使。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Scientists and medical experts are among the professionals trusted the most. Are they also the most suitable figures to convince the general public to get vaccinated? In a pre-registered experiment, we tested whether expert endorsement increases the effectiveness of debunking messages about COVID-19 vaccines. We monitored a sample of 2,277 people in Italy through a longitudinal study along the salient phases of the vaccination campaign. Participants received a series of messages endorsed by either medical researchers (experimental group) or by generic others (control). In order to minimise demand effects, we collected participants' responses always at ten days from the last debunking message. Whereas we did not find an increase in vaccination behaviour, we found that participants in the experimental group displayed higher intention to vaccinate, as well as more positive beliefs about the protectiveness of vaccines. The more debunking messages the participants received, the greater the increase in vaccination intention in the experimental group compared to control. This suggests that multiple exposure is critical for the effectiveness of expert-endorsed debunking messages. In addition, these effects are significant regardless of participants' trust toward science. Our results suggest that scientist and medical experts are not simply a generally trustworthy category but also a well suited messenger in contrasting disinformation during vaccination campaigns.
引用
- Ronzani P, Panizza F, Martini C, et al. Countering vaccine hesitancy through medical expert endorsement. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35750542. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.06.031
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。