关于COVID-19疫苗的公共卫生传播实验性预测试:医学背书、风险和利他主义的零结果
一项预注册的随机对照试验将全国代表性样本随机分配观看八种海报之一,海报在图片和消息上变化。结果显示海报引发不同反应,但所有干预消息的信任度均低于未提及疫苗的对照海报,且海报类型对接种意愿或愿意接种的时间均无影响。结论认为基于当时调查中疫苗犹豫最强相关因素的消息均无效。
要点
- 所有干预消息的信任度均低于未提及疫苗的对照消息(P<.001或P=.01)。
- 海报类型对接种意愿或愿意接种的时间均无影响。
- 零结果对于设计公共卫生运动可与阳性结果同等重要。
核心结论
- 尽管干预消息基于当时调查中疫苗犹豫的最强相关因素,但没有一个有效。
- 更近期的研究表明,聚焦COVID-19风险可能不如聚焦接种益处有效。
- 零结果对于设计公共卫生运动可与阳性结果同等重要,本研究为政府关于COVID-19疫苗的传播提供了信息。
研究设计与样本
- 预注册的随机对照试验。
- 大型全国代表性样本被随机分配观看八种海报之一。
- 海报在图片(全科医生或两名医院医生)和消息(对照含与疫苗接种无关的公共卫生指导、 pictured医生对疫苗的背书、背书加COVID-19风险信息、背书加风险信息并呼吁接种以保护亲友)上变化。
- 海报作为更大研究的一部分呈现。
- 主要结局为接种意愿和愿意多快接种。
主要发现
- 海报引发不同反应,表明参与者有所参与。
- 医院图片通常比全科医生图片更受偏好。
- 所有干预消息的信任度均低于未提及疫苗的对照消息:对照海报均值=5.65,SE=0.09 vs. 海报M均值=5.18,SE=0.09,p<.001;vs. 海报M+R均值=5.11,SE=0.09,p<.001;vs. 海报M+R+F均值=5.33,SE=0.09,p=.01。
- 海报类型对接种意愿或愿意接种的时间均无影响。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Vaccination campaigns against COVID-19 will only be successful if enough people want to take the vaccine. We tested a government communications intervention to encourage uptake. DESIGN: A pre-registered randomised controlled trial. METHODS: A large, nationally representative sample were randomly assigned to see one of eight posters. The posters varied by image (general practitioner or two hospital doctors) and message (control with public health guidance not related to vaccination, endorsement of the vaccine from the pictured doctor, endorsement with information about COVID-19 risk, endorsement with information about risk and appeal to get vaccinated to protect friends and family). The posters were presented as part of a larger study. The main outcomes were intention to be vaccinated and how soon people would be willing to be vaccinated. RESULTS: The posters induced different reactions indicating that participants had engaged with them. The hospital image was generally preferred to the GP image. Perhaps critically, all intervention messages were trusted less than a control message which did not mention the vaccine (Control Poster Mean = 5.65, SE = 0.09 vs. Poster M Mean = 5.18, SE = 0.09, p <.001; vs. Poster M + R Mean = 5.11, SE = 0.09, p <.001; vs. Poster M + R + F Mean = 5.33, SE = 0.09, p =.01). There were no effects of poster type on intention to take the vaccine or how soon people were willing to take it. CONCLUSION: Although the intervention messages were based on the strongest correlates of vaccine hesitancy identified by contemporaneous surveys, none was effective. More recent research suggests that focusing on the risk of COVID-19 may be less effective than focusing on the benefits of vaccination. Null findings can be as important as positive findings for designing public health campaigns. This study informed government communications about the COVID-19 vaccine.
引用
- Robertson DA, Mohr KS, Barjaková M, et al. Experimental pre-tests of public health communications on the COVID-19 vaccine: A null finding for medical endorsement, risk and altruism. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35606238. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.05.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。