文献速递免疫规划卫生政策与健康促进

儿童入托疫苗强制令且不允许依良心拒种豁免:一项准实验面板研究

Vaccine mandates on childcare entry without conscientious objection exemptions: A quasi-experimental panel study.
PubMed 文献 · Vaccine · 2022-04-29

该研究利用2016年1月至2019年12月澳大利亚免疫登记册的免疫覆盖率数据,结合各州政策实施时间差异,采用广义线性模型评估「不接种不入学」政策对免疫覆盖率的影响。结果显示政策实施后各年龄组覆盖率提升约1%,且效果因基线覆盖率分布和社会经济地位而异,高社会经济区域反应不显著。

要点

  • 2016年基线平均接种率:1岁组93.4%、2岁组91.2%、5岁组93.2%。
  • 政策实施后各年龄组覆盖率提升约1%,2岁和5岁组增幅较大。
  • 政策效果在覆盖率最低分位不显著,在高社会经济区域较小且不显著。

核心结论

  • 研究提示「不接种不入学」政策对免疫覆盖率有小的正向影响,且效果因既往覆盖率分布和社会经济地位而异,高社会经济区域反应不足及入托公平性仍是关切。

研究设计与样本

  • 准实验面板研究,链接2016年1月至2019年12月澳大利亚免疫登记册的免疫覆盖率与澳大利亚统计局区域层面协变量。
  • 利用各州政策推出时间差异,采用广义线性模型评估政策实施与覆盖率变化的关系,并进行分位数回归和亚组分析。
  • 原文未报告具体样本量。

主要发现

  • 2016年基线平均接种率:1岁组93.4%、2岁组91.2%、5岁组93.2%。
  • 控制时间趋势和区域特征后,政策实施与1岁组全程免疫覆盖率改善相关:第1年后0.15%(95%CI -0.23; 0.52),第2年后0.56%(95%CI 0.05; 1.07)。
  • 2岁组:第1年后0.49%(95%CI 0.00; 0.97),第2年后1.15%(95%CI 0.53; 1.77)。
  • 5岁组:第1年后0.38%(95%CI 0.08; 0.67),第2年后0.71%(95%CI 0.25; 1.16)。
  • 政策效果在免疫覆盖率分布最低分位不显著,在高社会经济区域较小且不显著。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVES: Examine the effect of No Jab No Play policies, which linked vaccine status to childcare service entry without allowing for personal belief exemptions, on immunisation coverage. STUDY DESIGN: Immunisation coverage rates from the Australian Immunisation Register were linked to regional level covariates from the Australian Bureau of Statistics between January 2016 and December 2019. Differential timings of policy rollouts across states were used to assess changes in coverage with the implementation of policies with generalised linear models. Quantile regression and subgroup analysis were also conducted to explore the variation in policy responses. RESULTS: Baseline mean vaccination rates in 2016 were 93.4% for one-year-olds, 91.2% for two-year-olds and 93.2% for five-year-olds. Increases in coverage post-policy were significant but small, at around 1% across age groups, with larger increases in two and five-year-olds. Accounting for aggregate time trends and regional characteristics, implementation of the policies was associated with improved full immunisation coverage rates for age one (post-year 1: 0.15% [95 %CI-0.23; 0.52]; post-year 2: 0.56% [95 %CI 0.05; 1.07]), age two (post-year 1: 0.49 [95 %CI: 0.00; 0.97]; post-year 2: 1.15% [95 %CI: 0.53; 1.77], and age five (post-year 1: 0.38% [95 %CI 0.08; 0.67]; post-year 2: 0.71% [95 %CI 0.25; 1.16]. The policy effect was dispersed and insignificant at the lowest quantiles of the distribution of immunisation coverage, and smaller and insignificant in the highest socioeconomic areas. CONCLUSION: Findings suggest that No Jab No Play policies had a small positive impact on immunisation coverage. This policy effect varied according to prior distribution of coverage and socio-economic status. Childcare access equity and unresponsiveness in high socioeconomic areas remain concerns.

来源:Vaccine,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Toll M, Li A. Vaccine mandates on childcare entry without conscientious objection exemptions: A quasi-experimental panel study. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35501181. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.03.071

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。