瑞士家长和提供者的疫苗犹豫与儿童非及时接种疫苗
研究调查瑞士1256名家长及其112名儿科医生(40名倾向补充医学,72名生物医学),使用PACV-5问卷识别中度(5-6分)和高度(7分以上)疫苗犹豫。结果显示家长和提供者的疫苗犹豫均与儿童非及时接种相关,且疫苗犹豫家长更可能咨询疫苗犹豫提供者。
要点
- 生物医学提供者无疫苗犹豫,补充医学提供者中9名中度、17名高度犹豫。
- 看中度或高度犹豫提供者的家长,自身疫苗犹豫的AOR分别为6.6和31.3。
- 中度或高度犹豫家长的儿童非及时接种的OR分别为1.9-3.8和7.1-12.3。
核心结论
- 家长和提供者的疫苗犹豫均与儿童非及时接种疫苗相关。
- 疫苗犹豫家长更可能咨询疫苗犹豫提供者,干预需主要针对疫苗犹豫提供者及其客户。
研究设计与样本
- 对1256名家长及其子女的儿科医生(N=112,40名倾向补充医学,72名生物医学)进行PACV-5问卷调查,基于接种记录定义非及时接种(推荐疫苗晚于官方推荐1个月以上)。
主要发现
- 生物医学提供者无疫苗犹豫,补充医学提供者中9名中度犹豫、17名高度犹豫。
- 看中度犹豫和高度犹豫提供者的家长,自身疫苗犹豫的AOR分别为6.6(95%CI 3.1-14.0)和31.3(95%CI 16.8-58.3)。
- 在所有疫苗 uptake 终点上,中度犹豫和高度犹豫家长的儿童非及时接种的OR分别为1.9-3.8和7.1-12.3。
- 看高度犹豫补充医学提供者的儿童非及时接种的OR为4.9-9.4。
- 看中度犹豫补充医学提供者的儿童,麻疹第一剂非及时接种的OR为3.3,脊灰/百日咳/破伤风第一剂非及时接种的OR为3.5。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Although medical providers are a trusted vaccination information source for parents, they do not universally support vaccination. Complementary medicine (CM) providers are particularly likely to hold vaccine hesitant (VH) views, and VH parents often consult with them. Little research compares VH of parents and providers, and if and how each is associated with uptake of recommended childhood vaccines. METHODS: We defined non-timely receipt as recommended vaccines given > 1 month later than officially recommended, based on vaccination records. We administered versions of the Parent Attitudes about Childhood Vaccines (PACV) 5-item survey instrument to 1256 parents and their children's pediatricians (N = 112, 40 CM-oriented, 72 biomedical [not CM-oriented]) to identify moderately (PACV-score 5-6) and highly (PACV-score 7+) hesitant providers/parents. We obtained multivariable adjusted odds ratios to test relationships between parental VH and provider type/VH, and between non-timely receipt of selected childhood vaccines and parental VH and provider type/VH. RESULTS: No biomedical providers were VH, 9 CM providers were moderately VH, and 17 were highly VH. Parents seeing moderately and highly hesitant providers had adjusted odds ratio (AOR) for being VH = 6.6 (95% confidence interval (CI), 3.1-14.0) and AOR = 31.3 (95% CI 16.8-58.3), respectively. Across all vaccine uptake endpoints, children of moderately and highly hesitant parents had 1.9-3.8 and 7.1-12.3 higher odds of non-timely vaccination, and children seeing highly hesitant CM providers had 4.9-9.4 higher odds. Children seeing moderately hesitant CM providers had 3.3 higher odds of non-timely vaccination for the 1st dose of measles and 3.5 higher odds for 1st dose of polio/pertussis/tetanus. CONCLUSION: VH by both parents and providers each is associated with non-timely childhood vaccination. As VH parents are more likely to consult with VH providers, interventions aimed at increasing timely vaccination need to primarily target VH providers and their clients.
引用
- Jafflin K, Deml MJ, Schwendener CL, et al. Parental and provider vaccine hesitancy and non-timely childhood vaccination in Switzerland. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35487812. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.04.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。