将其他服务与人类乳头瘤病毒疫苗接种相结合:生命历程早期的经验教训凸显对新政策与实施证据的需求
本文综述了将人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)疫苗接种与青少年其他基本卫生服务整合的全球策略、在低收入和中等收入国家(LMIC)的示范项目经验,以及坦桑尼亚「HPV Plus」实施案例,指出需更多操作层面证据以指导未来实施和政策。文章借鉴生命历程早期将产后家庭计划与婴儿免疫整合的13个LMIC经验,归纳出三种整合模式,并讨论其在学校、机构和社区三种HPV疫苗接种平台中的适用性。
要点
- 全球策略和LMIC示范项目已提出并测试将HPV疫苗接种与青少年其他基本卫生服务整合。
- 产后家庭计划与婴儿免疫整合的13个LMIC经验可提供三种整合模式供青少年HPV疫苗接种借鉴。
- 需将疫苗服务提供证据(覆盖率、效率、成本、成本效果)与整合实际操作细节结合,以评估最适合不同服务平台的模式。
核心结论
- 将HPV疫苗接种与更广泛的青少年健康与福祉协调行动将产生社会、经济和人口效益,这本身足以证明应更多关注整合方法。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为综述,回顾了已发表经验、全球指南以及坦桑尼亚「HPV Plus」实施案例,并综述了13个LMIC将产后家庭计划与婴儿免疫整合的经验。
主要发现
- 从家庭计划与免疫整合经验中归纳出三种整合模式:1)卫生人员提供疫苗接种和其他护理的多种任务和功能;2)在疫苗接种主要功能上增加次要任务;3)不同人员提供的匹配服务同址提供。
- 这些模式各有优势与不足,并以不同方式适用于学校、机构或社区三种HPV疫苗接种平台。
- 坦桑尼亚「HPV Plus」实施案例显示需要更多操作证据以指导未来实施和政策。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,HPV疫苗接种政策与规划首先需将现有疫苗服务提供证据(包括覆盖率、效率、成本、成本效果信息)与整合实际运作方式(操作细节和模式)相结合。
- 作者认为,还需将此与更贴合当地的青少年疾病负担和福祉其他决定因素评估相联系,以形成关于哪些其他服务可与HPV疫苗接种整合的新思考。
- 作者认为,需要采取以青少年为中心的新方法,设计适合其偏好和需求的服务。
- 作者认为,与老年女性宫颈癌筛查和治疗的潜在协同作用也需进一步探索。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Integration of vaccination against human papillomavirus (HPV) with other essential health services for adolescents has been proposed in global strategies and tested in demonstration projects in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC). Published experiences, global guidance, and one key example, the implementation of "HPV Plus" in Tanzania, all demonstrate the need for greater operational evidence to guide future implementation and policy. Review of experiences earlier in the life course, integrating post-partum family planning with infant immunization, show lessons from 13 LMICs that can apply to provision of adolescent health information and services alongside HPV vaccination. Three distinct models of integration emerge from this review comprising: 1) multiple tasks and functions by health staff providing vaccination and other care, or 2) secondary tasks added to the main function of vaccination, or 3) co-location of matched services provided by different staff. These models, with strengths and weaknesses demonstrated in family planning and immunization experiences, apply in different ways to the three main platforms used for HPV vaccination: school, facility or community. For HPV vaccination policy and programming, an initial need is to combine the existing evidence on vaccine service delivery - including coverage, efficiency, cost, and cost-effectiveness information - with what is known on how integration works in practice; the operational detail and models employed. This synthesis may enable assessment which models best suit the different service delivery platforms. An additional need is to link this with more tailored local assessments of the adolescent burden of disease and other determinants of their well-being to develop new thinking on what can and cannot be done to integrate other services alongside HPV vaccination. New approaches placing adolescents at the center are needed to design services tailored to their preferences and needs. The potential synergies with cervical cancer screening and treatment for older generations of women, also require further exploration. Coordinated action aligning HPV vaccination with broader adolescent health and wellbeing will generate social, economic and demographic benefits, which in themselves are sufficient justification to devote more attention to integrated approaches.
引用
- Morgan C, Giattas MR, Holroyd T, et al. Integration of other services with human papillomavirus vaccination; lessons from earlier in the life course highlight the need for new policy and implementation evidence. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35105493. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.12.066
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。