免疫债务还是疫苗危机?关于新兴COVID-19变异株疫苗接受度与媒体框架的多方法证据
该研究采用内容分析与准实验相结合的多方法,解析巴基斯坦主流媒体在COVID-19相关报道中使用的框架策略。内容分析发现媒体广泛使用不确定性、冲突、后果和行动框架,而非新证据和 reassurance 框架;涉及720名参与者的准实验表明,引发恐惧(后果和不确定性)及行动提示的媒体框架产生消息一致性效应,使接收者更支持接种疫苗。
要点
- 媒体在COVID-19报道中广泛使用不确定性、冲突、后果和行动框架,较少使用新证据和 reassurance 框架。
- 涉及720名参与者的准实验显示,后果和不确定性等引发恐惧的框架及行动提示产生消息一致性效应,使接收者更支持接种疫苗。
- 研究为媒体框架策略提供新证据,以开展更有针对性、有意义和有效的运动,提高公众对COVID-19疫苗的接受度。
核心结论
- 媒体框架中引发恐惧(后果和不确定性)及行动提示的消息一致性效应使接收者更支持接种疫苗。
研究设计与样本
- 研究采用多方法(内容分析和准实验),内容分析解析巴基斯坦主流媒体的框架实践,准实验涉及720名参与者并操纵六种框架。
主要发现
- 内容分析发现媒体在COVID-19相关运动中广泛使用不确定性、冲突、后果和行动框架,而非新证据和 reassurance 框架。
- 准实验涉及720名参与者,操纵不确定性、冲突、后果、行动、新证据和 reassurance 六种框架,发现引发恐惧(后果和不确定性)及行动提示的框架产生消息一致性效应,使接收者更支持接种疫苗。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为研究结果为媒体框架策略提供新证据,可用来开展更有针对性、有意义和有效的运动,以提高公众对COVID-19疫苗的接受度。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Renewed COVID-19 outbreaks, stemming from the highly infectious Delta and Omicron variants, prompted rising fears of a 'pandemic among the unvaccinated'. To address this prevalent vaccination crisis, media framing communication strategies can amplify the scientific evidence on COVID-19 vaccines to reach diverse geographic and socio-economic communities. The critical role of media framing strategies to engage and encourage large populations regarding vaccine acceptance has been rarely studied, despite growing evidence on vaccine hesitancy. The present study used a multi-method approach (i.e., content analysis and quasi-experiments) that unpacked the framing practices employed by the mainstream media in Pakistan. The findings of the content analysis revealed that the media extensively used uncertainty, conflict, consequences, and action rather than new evidence and reassurance frames in its COVID-19 related campaigns. In a series of quasi-experiments involving 720 participants, we manipulated these six frames of COVID-19 related news coverage (i.e., uncertainty, conflict, consequences, action, new evidence, and reassurance) to investigate the underlying mechanism that influences vaccine acceptance. The findings established that the message-consistent effects of media frames manifesting fear (e.g., consequence and uncertainty) and action cues made receivers more supportive of vaccination. The present study findings theoretically address the calls for a more inclusive "community-health reporting model", besides offering new evidence on the media framing strategies to deliver more targeted, meaningful, and effective campaigns to raise public acceptance for COVID-19 vaccines.
引用
- Yousaf M, Hassan Raza S, Mahmood N, et al. Immunity debt or vaccination crisis? A multi-method evidence on vaccine acceptance and media framing for emerging COVID-19 variants. Vaccine. 2022. PMID: 35153094. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2022.01.055
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。