2021年8月16日至10月31日加利福尼亚州洛杉矶县过渡性幼儿园至12年级学校「检测留校」策略评估
2021年9月20日至10月31日,洛杉矶县78个学区中半数允许检测留校(TTS),2067所学校中432所(21%)采用。TTS学校实施后学生COVID-19发病率未增加,20起疫情中未发现三级传播;TTS学区与非TTS学区学生发病率比值前后相似(率比=0.5)。非TTS学校估计损失92455个到校日,而TTS学校隔离学生无损失日。
要点
- TTS学校实施后学生COVID-19发病率未增加,20起疫情中未发现三级传播。
- TTS学区与非TTS学区学生发病率比值前后相似,率比为0.5。
- 非TTS学校损失92455个到校日,TTS学校隔离学生无损失日。
核心结论
- 洛杉矶县初步数据提示,学校TTS策略不增加SARS-CoV-2校内传播,可能大幅减少到校日损失,但TTS可能存在实施障碍并需要部分学校无法获得的资源。
- 持续简化学校检疫策略可能有助于确保所有学生获得安全到校教育。
- 尽管接种疫苗仍是保护≥5岁人群免受COVID-19感染的首要公共卫生建议,学校可考虑将TTS作为未完全接种疫苗的学校暴露学生留在教室的选项,替代居家隔离。
研究设计与样本
- 评估洛杉矶县公共卫生局(LAC DPH)实施的TTS策略,2021年9月20日至10月31日在78个学区中开展,其中半数允许TTS。
- 2067所学校中432所(21%)采用TTS。
主要发现
- TTS学校实施后学生COVID-19发病率未增加,20起已识别疫情中未发现三级传播。
- TTS学区与非TTS学区学生COVID-19发病率比值在TTS采用前后相似(率比=0.5)。
- 2021年9月20日至10月31日期间,非TTS学校估计损失92455个到校日,而TTS学校隔离学生无损失日。
- 非TTS学校以资源相关原因未采用TTS,其中75%位于LAC最弱势社区。
关键数值与推荐
- TTS策略允许在校暴露于SARS-CoV-2感染者的未接种学生,若感染者和暴露者全程正确持续佩戴口罩,可在检疫期间留校。
- 留校检疫期间,暴露学生须保持无症状、在校佩戴口罩、每周接受两次SARS-CoV-2检测。
- TTS学区与非TTS学区学生COVID-19发病率比值在TTS采用前后相似(率比=0.5)。
临床怎么用
- 学校可考虑将TTS作为未完全接种疫苗的学校暴露学生留在教室的选项,替代居家隔离。
- 接种疫苗仍是保护≥5岁人群免受COVID-19感染的首要公共卫生建议。
- TTS可能存在实施障碍并需要部分学校无法获得的资源。
- 持续简化学校检疫策略可能有助于确保所有学生获得安全到校教育。
局限性
- TTS可能存在实施障碍并需要部分学校无法获得的资源。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
On July 12, 2021, the California Department of Public Health updated COVID-19 school guidance, allowing a Test to Stay (TTS) strategy to increase access to in-person learning* (1). The TTS strategy enabled unvaccinated students, exposed in school to a person infected with SARS-CoV-2 (the virus that causes COVID-19), to remain in school while under quarantine, if both the infected person and the exposed person wore masks correctly and consistently throughout the exposure. To stay in school during the quarantine period, the exposed student must remain asymptomatic, wear a mask at school, and undergo twice weekly testing for SARS-CoV-2. To date, few studies have evaluated the impact of TTS on transmission (2-4). This study evaluated a TTS strategy implemented by Los Angeles County Department of Public Health (LAC DPH). During September 20-October 31, 2021, among 78 school districts, one half permitted TTS; in total, 432 (21%) of 2,067 schools adopted TTS. TTS schools did not experience increases in COVID-19 incidence among students after TTS implementation, and in 20 identified outbreaks in TTS schools,† no tertiary transmission was identified. The ratio of student COVID-19 incidence in TTS districts to that in non-TTS districts was similar before and after TTS adoption (rate ratio = 0.5). Non-TTS schools lost an estimated 92,455 in-person school days during September 20-October 31 while students were in quarantine, compared with no lost days among quarantined students in TTS schools. Non-TTS schools cited resource-related reasons for not adopting TTS; 75% of these schools were in LAC's most disadvantaged neighborhoods. Preliminary data from LAC suggest that a school-based TTS strategy does not increase school transmission of SARS-CoV-2, and might greatly reduce loss of in-person school days; however, TTS might have barriers to implementation and require resources that are not available for some schools. Continued efforts to simplify school quarantine strategies might help to ensure that all students have access to safe in-person education. Although vaccination remains the leading public health recommendation to protect against COVID-19 for persons aged ≥5 years, schools might consider TTS as an option for allowing students with a school exposure who are not fully vaccinated to remain in the classroom as an alternative to home quarantine.
引用
- Harris-McCoy K, Lee VC, Munna C, et al. Evaluation of a Test to Stay Strategy in Transitional Kindergarten Through Grade 12 Schools - Los Angeles County, California, August 16-October 31, 2021. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2021. PMID: 34968371. doi:10.15585/mmwr.mm705152e1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。