以种族和族裔评价加州奥克兰全市学校流感疫苗接种项目:一项匹配队列研究
研究采用匹配队列设计,比较奥克兰干预区与西康特拉科斯塔县对照区学校,2014至2018年通过横断面调查和监测数据评估全市学校流感疫苗接种项目按种族和族裔分层的效果。结果显示项目与更高的接种覆盖率和更低的流感住院率相关,但关联因种族和族裔而异,仅靠学校接种项目可能不足以确保公平的流感结局。
要点
- 2017-18学年流感疫苗接种覆盖率差异:白人学生21.0%,西班牙裔/拉丁裔学生13.4%,高于亚裔/太平洋岛民8.9%、黑人5.9%和多种族6.3%。
- 黑人及多种族照护者更常担忧疫苗有效性或安全性;干预区后勤障碍较对照区少,白人学生差异最大。
- 2016-17和2017-18学年白人/亚裔及太平洋岛民全年龄流感住院率干预区低于对照区,2017-18黑人老年人亦较低。
核心结论
- 学校流感疫苗接种项目与更高的疫苗接种覆盖率和更低的流感住院率相关,但关联因种族和族裔而异。
- 仅靠学校流感疫苗接种项目可能不足以确保公平的流感结局。
研究设计与样本
- 匹配队列研究,使用多变量匹配将加州奥克兰干预区学校与加州西康特拉科斯塔县对照区学校配对。
- 通过横断面调查测量照护者报告的学生疫苗接种状态,并使用监测数据估计实验室确诊流感住院发病率。
- 按种族和族裔分层估计两区疫苗接种覆盖率差异、未接种原因差异以及流感住院发病率的双重差分(DID)。
主要发现
- 干预区与对照区流感疫苗接种覆盖率差异:白人学生2017-18学年差异21.0%(95%CI:9.7%,32.3%),西班牙裔/拉丁裔学生差异13.4%(95%CI:8.8%,18.0%),亚裔/太平洋岛民学生差异8.9%(95%CI:1.3%,16.5%),黑人学生差异5.9%(95%CI:-2.2%,14.0%),多种族学生差异6.3%(95%CI:-1.8%,14.3%)。
- 对疫苗有效性或安全性的担忧在黑人及多种族照护者中更常见;后勤障碍在干预区较对照区少,白人学生差异最大。
- 两区2017-18学年黑人住院率均高于其他种族/族裔:干预区每10万人111.5例,对照区每10万人134.1例。
- 白人/亚裔及太平洋岛民全年龄流感住院发病率干预区低于对照区:2016-17学年DID为每10万人-25.14(95%CI:-40.14,-10.14),2017-18学年DID为每10万人-36.6(95%CI:-52.7,-20.5)。
- 2017-18学年黑人老年人流感住院发病率干预区低于对照区,DID为每10万人-282.2(95%CI:-508.4,-56.1)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Increasing influenza vaccination coverage in school-aged children may substantially reduce community transmission. School-located influenza vaccinations (SLIV) aim to promote vaccinations by increasing accessibility, which may be especially beneficial to race/ethnicity groups that face high barriers to preventative care. Here, we evaluate the effectiveness of a city-wide SLIV program by race/ethnicity from 2014 to 2018. METHODS: We used multivariate matching to pair schools in the intervention district in Oakland, CA with schools in a comparison district in West Contra Costa County, CA. We distributed cross-sectional surveys to measure caregiver-reported student vaccination status and estimated differences in vaccination coverage levels and reasons for non-vaccination between districts stratifying by race/ethnicity. We estimated difference-in-differences (DID) of laboratory confirmed influenza hospitalization incidence between districts stratified by race/ethnicity using surveillance data. RESULTS: Differences in influenza vaccination coverage in the intervention vs. comparison district were larger among White (2017-18: 21.0% difference [95% CI: 9.7%, 32.3%]) and Hispanic/Latino (13.4% [8.8%, 18.0%]) students than Asian/Pacific Islander (API) (8.9% [1.3%, 16.5%]), Black (5.9% [-2.2%, 14.0%]), and multiracial (6.3% [-1.8%, 14.3%)) students. Concerns about vaccine effectiveness or safety were more common among Black and multiracial caregivers. Logistical barriers were less common in the intervention vs. comparison district, with the largest difference among White students. In both districts, hospitalizations in 2017-18 were higher in Blacks (Intervention: 111.5 hospitalizations per 100,00; Comparison: 134.1 per 100,000) vs. other races/ethnicities. All-age influenza hospitalization incidence was lower in the intervention site vs. comparison site among White/API individuals in 2016-17 (DID -25.14 per 100,000 [95% CI: -40.14, -10.14]) and 2017-18 (-36.6 per 100,000 [-52.7, -20.5]) and Black older adults in 2017-18 (-282.2 per 100,000 (-508.4, -56.1]), but not in other groups. CONCLUSIONS: SLIV was associated with higher vaccination coverage and lower influenza hospitalization, but associations varied by race/ethnicity. SLIV alone may be insufficient to ensure equitable influenza outcomes.
引用
- Nguyen AT, Arnold BF, Kennedy CJ, et al. Evaluation of a city-wide school-located influenza vaccination program in Oakland, California with respect to race and ethnicity: A matched cohort study. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34872797. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.11.073
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。