母亲回忆估算儿童疫苗接种覆盖率的有效性——尼日利亚的证据
在尼日利亚埃努古州对1254名12-23月龄儿童母亲开展横断面调查,比较居家接种卡与母亲回忆两种数据源,其中578名(46.1%)有接种卡的母亲纳入分析;结果显示两种数据源一致率高(所有疫苗≥91.0%),回忆敏感性高但特异性低,回忆数据总体低估覆盖率,回忆偏倚与农村居住和未接受产后保健显著相关。
要点
- 有接种卡的母亲中,两种数据源一致率高(所有疫苗≥91.0%)。
- 母亲回忆对所有疫苗敏感性高,但特异性低。
- 回忆偏倚与农村居住和未接受产后保健显著相关。
核心结论
- 在缺乏接种卡的情况下,母亲对BCG、OPV、DPT、麻疹、黄热病和维生素A补充的回忆是估算该尼日利亚研究背景下儿童疫苗接种覆盖率的有效工具。
- 需要在更高次国家级和国家层面开展更多研究来证实这些发现。
研究设计与样本
- 2020年7月在尼日利亚埃努古州开展社区横断面调查,纳入1254名12-23月龄儿童母亲。
- 通过居家接种卡和母亲回忆两种数据源收集BCG、OPV、DPT、麻疹、黄热病和维生素A补充的接种数据。
- 分析纳入578名(46.1%)有接种卡的母亲,评估两种数据源一致性,估计母亲回忆的敏感性和特异性,并构建多变量回归模型识别与回忆偏倚相关的社会人口学因素。
主要发现
- 两种数据源的疫苗接种覆盖率水平总体相似,但基于回忆的数据总体上低估了覆盖率。
- 两种数据源的一致性高,所有疫苗类型均≥91.0%;因低报导致的回忆偏倚总体高于因高报导致的回忆偏倚。
- 母亲回忆对所有疫苗类型的敏感性高,而特异性在各疫苗类型中均低。
- 在所有疫苗中,母亲回忆偏倚与农村居住和未接受产后保健显著相关。
局限性
- 需要在更高次国家级和国家层面开展更多研究来证实这些发现。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Vaccination coverage surveys in low- and middle-income countries typically estimate vaccination coverage using data from vaccination cards, parental recall, or a combination of the two. However, these surveys are often complicated by the pervasive absence of vaccination cards, forcing researchers to rely on parental recall. We assessed the validity of mothers' recall against home-based vaccination cards using data from a community-based household survey in Nigeria. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey of 1,254 mothers of children aged 12-23 months was performed in Enugu State, Nigeria in July 2020. Data on vaccination status for BCG, OPV, DPT, Measles, Yellow fever, and Vitamin A supplement were collected using two data sources: home-based vaccination cards and mothers' recall. We evaluated the level of agreement between the two data sources; estimated the sensitivity and specificity of mothers' recalls; and computed multivariable regression models to identify socio-demographic factors associated with mothers' recall bias. RESULTS: Out of 1,254 mothers interviewed, 578 (46.1%) mothers with vaccination cards were included in this analysis. Vaccination coverage levels were generally similar across data sources, though recall-based data generally underestimated the coverage. The level of agreement between the two data sources was high (≥91.0% for all vaccine types) with recall bias due to under-reporting generally higher than recall bias due to over-reporting. The sensitivity of parental recalls was high for all vaccine types, while the specificity was low across vaccine types. Across all vaccines, mothers recall bias was significantly associated with the rural residence and not receiving postnatal care. CONCLUSION: In the absence of vaccination cards, mothers' recall of their children' vaccination status for BCG, OPV, DPT, Measles, Yellow fever and Vitamin A is a valid instrument for estimating childhood vaccination coverage in this setting in Nigeria. However, additional research is needed to confirm these findings at higher sub-national and national levels.
引用
- Eze P, Aniebo CL, Agu UJ, et al. Validity of maternal recall for estimating childhood vaccination coverage - Evidence from Nigeria. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34863616. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.11.060
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。