COVID-19疫苗强制接种:一项澳大利亚态度研究
该研究先通过概念分析梳理全球疫苗强制接种的类型与实施情况,再对44名西澳大利亚人进行质性访谈,分析其对不同强制接种政策的态度。结果显示,参与者对与疾病预防限制相关的强制措施支持度最高,对医疗豁免支持但很少支持宗教或个人信仰豁免,且对雇主或企业实施的强制接种也有一定支持。
要点
- 参与者对与疾病预防限制相关的强制接种措施最为支持。
- 参与者对雇主或企业实施的强制接种支持度相似,且较少担忧问责问题。
- 参与者多支持由专科医生严格监管的医疗豁免,对宗教或个人信仰豁免兴趣不大。
核心结论
- 参与者习惯于疫苗强制接种及严格封锁和旅行限制,这些因素似乎影响其对COVID-19疫苗强制接种的总体开放态度,尤其当明确与高风险环境中的疾病预防相关时。
研究设计与样本
- 概念研究从现有工作、新闻报道和全球立法干预中归纳强制接种类别;质性研究访谈44名西澳大利亚人,使用NVivo 12分析数据。
主要发现
- 参与者对强制措施是激励还是惩罚表现出紧张和困惑,许多人支持对未接种疫苗者施加严厉后果,即使表面上反对强制接种。
- 与疾病预防限制相关的强制措施最受欢迎。
- 对雇主或企业实施的强制接种支持度相似,参与者对将公共卫生决策委托给私营部门可能带来的问责问题关注较少。
- 参与者多支持由专科医生授予的严格监管的医疗豁免,对宗教或个人信仰豁免兴趣不大。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The rollout of vaccines against COVID-19 is prompting governments and the private sector to adopt mandates. However, there has been little conceptual analysis of the types of mandates available, nor empirical analysis of how the public thinks about different mandates and why. Our conceptual study examines available instruments, how they have been implemented pre-COVID, and their use for COVID-19 globally. Then, our qualitative study reports the acceptability of such measures in Western Australia, which has experienced very limited community transmission, posing an interesting scenario for vaccine acceptance and acceptability of measures to enforce it. METHOD: Our conceptual study developed categories of mandates from extant work, news reports, and legislative interventions globally. Then, our empirical study asked 44 West Australians about their attitudes towards potential mandatory policies, with data analysed using NVivo 12. RESULTS: Our novel studies contribute richness and depth to emerging literature on the types and varying acceptability of vaccine requirements. Participants demonstrated tensions and confusion about whether instruments were incentives or punishments, and many supported strong consequences for non-vaccination even if they ostensibly opposed mandates. Those attached to restrictions for disease prevention were most popular. There were similar degrees of support for mandates imposed by employers or businesses, with participants showing little concern for potential issues of accountability linked to public health decisions delegated to the private sector. Participants mostly supported tightly regulated medical exemptions granted by specialists, with little interest in religious or personal belief exemptions. CONCLUSION: Our participants are used to being governed by vaccine mandates, and now by rigorous lockdown and travel restrictions that have ensured limited local COVID-19 disease and transmission. These factors appear influential in their general openness to COVID-19 vaccine mandates, especially when linked explicitly to the prevention of disease in high-risk settings.
引用
- Attwell K, Rizzi M, McKenzie L, et al. COVID-19 vaccine Mandates: An Australian attitudinal study. Vaccine. 2021. PMID: 34872796. doi:10.1016/j.vaccine.2021.11.056
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。