文献速递心境障碍焦虑、强迫与应激相关障碍

抑郁与焦虑症状患者对提供者文化胜任力的种族与族裔差异

Racial and ethnic differences in perception of provider cultural competence among patients with depression and anxiety symptoms: a retrospective, population-based, cross-sectional analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Lancet Psychiatry · 2021-09-23

基于美国2017年全国健康访谈调查(NHIS)的回顾性横断面分析纳入3910名成年人,考察种族、族裔与心理健康状况同患者自报的提供者文化胜任力重要性之间的关联。抑郁症状患者、种族或族裔少数群体更希望提供者理解或共享其文化,却更少能经常遇到共享其文化的提供者,抑郁患者中差异尤为明显。

要点

  • 抑郁症状患者更希望提供者理解或共享其文化(aOR 1·57,95%CI 1·13-2·19,p=0·008)。
  • 黑人或亚裔 American、混血及 Hispanic 人群更希望获得文化胜任照护,但更少能见到共享其文化的提供者。
  • 在抑郁症状患者中,黑人、American Indian 或 Alaskan Native 及 Hispanic 人群更希望提供者具备文化胜任力。

核心结论

  • 种族和族裔差异存在于患者对提供者文化胜任力的感知中,且在抑郁患者中更为突出。
  • 培养文化胜任且谦逊的照护方式对精神卫生提供者至关重要。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性、基于人群的横断面研究,数据来自美国2017年NHIS成人自报问卷。
  • 纳入完成文化胜任力补充问题与成人功能与残疾调查、年龄至少18岁的应答者,共3910人。
  • 采用多变量有序逻辑回归估计社会人口学特征、自报健康状况与抑郁/焦虑症状同结局变量的调整比值比(aOR)。

主要发现

  • 抑郁症状患者较无抑郁或焦虑症状者更希望提供者理解或共享其文化(aOR 1·57,95%CI 1·13-2·19,p=0·008)。
  • 黑人较白人(aOR 2·54,95%CI 1·86-3·48,p=0·008)、亚裔美国人较白人(aOR 2·57,95%CI 1·66-3·99,p<0·001)、混血较白人(aOR 1·69,95%CI 1·01-2·82,p=0·045)更希望提供者理解或共享其文化。
  • Hispanic 较非 Hispanic 更希望提供者理解或共享其文化(aOR 2·69,95%CI 2·02-3·60,p<0·001)。
  • 抑郁症状患者较无抑郁或焦虑症状者更少报告经常见到共享其文化的提供者(aOR 0·63,95%CI 0·41-0·96,p=0·030)。
  • 黑人较白人(aOR 0·56,95%CI 0·38-0·84,p=0·005)、亚裔美国人较白人(aOR 0·38,95%CI 0·20-0·72,p=0·003)、混血较白人(aOR 0·35,95%CI 0·19-0·64,p=0·001)、Hispanic 较非 Hispanic(aOR 0·61,95%CI 0·42-0·89,p=0·010)更少报告经常见到共享其文化的提供者。

关键数值与推荐

  • 抑郁症状定义:自报症状至少每周一次或更频繁,且最近一次症状强度为「介于一点和很多之间」或「很多」。
  • 样本平均年龄52岁(IQR 36-64);男性1422人(39·2%,样本权重调整),女性2488人(60·9%)。
  • 种族构成:白人3290人(82·7%)、黑人346人(9·1%)、American Indian 或 Alaskan Native 31人(0·8%)、亚裔美国人144人(4·8%)、混血99人(2·6%)。
  • 族裔构成:Hispanic 380人(12·5%),非 Hispanic 3530人(87·5%)。

临床怎么用

  • 在精神心理科诊疗中应主动评估患者对提供者理解或共享其文化的需求,尤其针对抑郁症状患者与种族/族裔少数群体。
  • 可将文化胜任力与文化谦逊纳入临床沟通与服务安排,以回应少数群体患者更希望被理解文化背景的诉求。

局限性

  • 研究为回顾性横断面设计,无法推断因果关系。
  • 数据来自自报问卷,症状与文化胜任力感知可能存在报告偏倚。
  • 原文未报告其他局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Racial and ethnic minorities face disparities in access to health care. Culturally competent care might lessen these disparities. Few studies have studied the patients' view of providers' cultural competence, especially in psychiatric care. We aimed to examine the associations of race, ethnicity, and mental health status with patient-reported importance of provider cultural competence. METHODS: Our retrospective, population-based, cross-sectional study used data extracted from self-reported questionnaires of adults aged at least 18 years who participated in the US National Health Interview Survey (NHIS; 2017 cycle). We included data on all respondents who answered supplementary cultural competence questions and the Adult Functioning and Disability survey within the NHIS. We classified participants as having anxiety or depression if they reported symptoms at least once a week or more often, and responded that the last time they had symptoms the intensity was "somewhere between a little and a lot" or "a lot." Participant answers to cultural competency survey questions (participant desire for providers to understand or share their culture, and frequency of access to providers who share their culture) were the outcome variables. Multivariable ordinal logistic regressions were used to estimate adjusted odds ratios (aORs) for the outcome variables in relation to sociodemographic characteristics (including race and ethnicity), self-reported health status, and presence of symptoms of depression, anxiety, or both. FINDINGS: 3910 people had available data for analysis. Mean age was 52 years (IQR 36-64). 1422 (39·2%, sample weight adjusted) of the participants were men and 2488 (60·9%) were women. 3290 (82·7%) were White, 346 (9·1%) were Black or African American, 31 (0·8%) were American Indian or Alaskan Native, 144 (4·8%) were Asian American, and 99 (2·6%) were Mixed Race. 380 (12·5%) identified as Hispanic ethnicity and 3530 (87·5%) as non-Hispanic. Groups who were more likely to express a desire for their providers to share or understand their culture included participants who had depression symptoms (vs those without depression or anxiety symptoms, aOR 1·57 [95% CI 1·13-2·19], p=0·008) and participants who were of a racial minority group (Black vs White, aOR 2·54 [1·86-3·48], p=0·008; Asian American vs White, aOR 2·57 [1·66-3·99], p<0·001; and Mixed Race vs White, aOR 1·69 [1·01-2·82], p=0·045) or ethnic minority group (Hispanic vs non-Hispanic, aOR 2·69 [2·02-3·60], p<0·001); these groups were less likely to report frequently being able to see providers who shared their culture (patients with depression symptoms vs those without depression or anxiety symptoms, aOR 0·63 (0·41-0·96); p=0·030; Black vs White, aOR 0·56 [0·38-0·84], p=0·005; Asian American vs White, aOR 0·38 [0·20-0·72], p=0·003; Mixed Race vs White, aOR 0·35 [0·19-0·64], p=0·001; Hispanic vs non-Hispanic, aOR 0·61 [0·42-0·89], p=0·010). On subgroup analysis of participants reporting depression symptoms, patients who identified their race as Black or African American, or American Indian or Alaskan Native, and those who identified as Hispanic ethnicity, were more likely to report a desire for provider cultural competence. INTERPRETATION: Racial and ethnic disparities exist in how patients perceive their providers' cultural competence, and disparities are pronounced in patients with depression. Developing a culturally competent and humble approach to care is crucial for mental health providers. FUNDING: None.

来源:Lancet Psychiatry,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Eken HN, Dee EC, Powers AR, et al. Racial and ethnic differences in perception of provider cultural competence among patients with depression and anxiety symptoms: a retrospective, population-based, cross-sectional analysis. Lancet Psychiatry. 2021. PMID: 34563316. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(21)00285-6

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。