精神病理预测工具的可推广性与跨诊断验证:NAPLS-2风险计算器在PRONIA队列中的独立验证与改进
该研究在PRONIA多中心队列的334例临床高风险或近期起病抑郁患者中验证了NAPLS-2精神病风险计算器,校准后对精神病发作的平衡准确率在UHR、CHR和CHR|ROD亚组分别为68%、67%和70%;更宽泛的风险定义产生更准确的风险计算器,支持向量机在CHR|ROD中表现最优。
要点
- NAPLS-2计算器经校准后在PRONIA队列中预测精神病发作的平衡准确率为67%–70%。
- 更宽泛的风险定义(CHR|ROD)产生更准确的风险计算器,优于UHR定义。
- 衰减精神病症状跨风险水平预测精神病发作,年轻和加工速度下降在宽泛风险队列中更相关。
核心结论
- 临床-神经认知机器学习模型在年轻情感和CHR综合征患者中可促进更精确和可推广的精神病预测。
研究设计与样本
- 在PRONIA多中心研究的334例临床高风险或近期起病抑郁患者中验证NAPLS-2计算器,其中26例转为精神病。
- 患者分为UHR、CHR和CHR|ROD三个风险富集水平,采用交互外部验证评估风险富集和不同预测算法对预后性能的影响。
主要发现
- 校准后NAPLS-2模型在PRONIA-UHR队列预测精神病的平衡准确率为68%(敏感度73%,特异度63%)。
- 校准后NAPLS-2模型在CHR队列的平衡准确率为67%(敏感度74%,特异度60%),在CHR|ROD患者中为70%(敏感度73%,特异度66%)。
- 在PRONIA-CHR|ROD中推导多模型并在NAPLS-2-UHR患者中验证,确认更宽泛风险定义产生更准确的风险计算器(CHR|ROD基于vs UHR基于性能:67%[68%,66%] vs 58%[61%,56%])。
- 支持向量机在CHR|ROD中表现更优(BAC=71%),而岭逻辑回归和支持向量机在CHR(BAC=67%)和UHR队列(BAC=65%)中表现相似。
- 衰减精神病症状跨风险水平预测精神病发作,而年轻和加工速度下降在更宽泛风险队列中越来越相关。
临床怎么用
- 临床-神经认知机器学习模型可用于年轻情感和CHR综合征患者的精神病风险预测,支持跨诊断应用。
- 更宽泛的风险定义(包括近期起病抑郁)可能提高风险计算器的预测准确性,支持在更广泛风险人群中实施早期干预。
局限性
- 研究结论指出未来需在大规模临床试验中探究这些模型的治疗效用。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Transition to psychosis is among the most adverse outcomes of clinical high-risk (CHR) syndromes encompassing ultra-high risk (UHR) and basic symptom states. Clinical risk calculators may facilitate an early and individualized interception of psychosis, but their real-world implementation requires thorough validation across diverse risk populations, including young patients with depressive syndromes. METHODS: We validated the previously described NAPLS-2 (North American Prodrome Longitudinal Study 2) calculator in 334 patients (26 with transition to psychosis) with CHR or recent-onset depression (ROD) drawn from the multisite European PRONIA (Personalised Prognostic Tools for Early Psychosis Management) study. Patients were categorized into three risk enrichment levels, ranging from UHR, over CHR, to a broad-risk population comprising patients with CHR or ROD (CHR|ROD). We assessed how risk enrichment and different predictive algorithms influenced prognostic performance using reciprocal external validation. RESULTS: After calibration, the NAPLS-2 model predicted psychosis with a balanced accuracy (BAC) (sensitivity, specificity) of 68% (73%, 63%) in the PRONIA-UHR cohort, 67% (74%, 60%) in the CHR cohort, and 70% (73%, 66%) in patients with CHR|ROD. Multiple model derivation in PRONIA-CHR|ROD and validation in NAPLS-2-UHR patients confirmed that broader risk definitions produced more accurate risk calculators (CHR|ROD-based vs. UHR-based performance: 67% [68%, 66%] vs. 58% [61%, 56%]). Support vector machines were superior in CHR|ROD (BAC = 71%), while ridge logistic regression and support vector machines performed similarly in CHR (BAC = 67%) and UHR cohorts (BAC = 65%). Attenuated psychotic symptoms predicted psychosis across risk levels, while younger age and reduced processing speed became increasingly relevant for broader risk cohorts. CONCLUSIONS: Clinical-neurocognitive machine learning models operating in young patients with affective and CHR syndromes facilitate a more precise and generalizable prediction of psychosis. Future studies should investigate their therapeutic utility in large-scale clinical trials.
引用
- Koutsouleris N, Worthington M, Dwyer DB, et al. Toward Generalizable and Transdiagnostic Tools for Psychosis Prediction: An Independent Validation and Improvement of the NAPLS-2 Risk Calculator in the Multisite PRONIA Cohort. Biol Psychiatry. 2021. PMID: 34482951. doi:10.1016/j.biopsych.2021.06.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。