双相障碍服务使用者对自我约束指令接受或拒绝原因的质性研究
该质性研究基于英国Bipolar UK的在线调查,分析565名自报临床诊断双相障碍者对自我约束指令看法的开放式回答。463人(82%)支持,其中411人(89%)以发病时思维和决策确定性扭曲为主要理由;37人(7%)矛盾,65人(12%)拒绝。拒绝者提及操作顾虑、病时思维有效性和潜在人权侵犯。
要点
- 82%的双相障碍服务使用者支持自我约束指令,主要因发病时决策扭曲。
- 矛盾与拒绝主要涉及指令起草实施的操作顾虑及人权担忧。
- 结果为将自我约束指令纳入精神卫生服务提供了实证支持。
核心结论
- 双相障碍服务使用者对自我约束指令的支持率高,主要理由是发病时思维和决策确定性扭曲;矛盾与拒绝则多因操作顾虑、病时思维有效性和潜在人权侵犯。
主要发现
- 565名参与者中463人(82%)支持自我约束指令,其中411人(89%)以发病时思维和决策确定性扭曲为主要理由。
- 37人(7%)持矛盾态度,主要顾虑指令的起草与实施等操作问题。
- 65人(12%)拒绝自我约束指令,理由包括操作顾虑、病时思维有效性和潜在人权侵犯。
临床怎么用
- 研究结果为将自我约束指令引入精神卫生服务及推进预先决策实践与政策提供实证支持。
- 研究结果可能有助于回应对保留决策能力时实施该指令的伦理担忧。
局限性
- 样本以英国白人为主,可能限制结果的代表性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Self-binding directives instruct clinicians to overrule treatment refusal during future severe episodes of illness. These directives are promoted as having the potential to increase autonomy for individuals with severe episodic mental illness. Although lived experience is central to their creation, the views of service users on self-binding directives have not been investigated substantially. This study aimed to explore whether reasons for endorsement, ambivalence, or rejection given by service users with bipolar disorder can address concerns regarding self-binding directives, decision-making capacity, and human rights. METHODS: This qualitative study used data from an internet-based survey distributed to the mailing list of the UK charity Bipolar UK, which contained multiple closed and open questions on advance decision making for patients with bipolar disorder. We included participants who reported that they have been diagnosed with bipolar disorder by a professional (doctor or psychiatrist). In a previous study, quantitative analysis of a closed question about self-binding directives had shown endorsement among a high proportion of participants with bipolar disorder who completed the survey. In this study, we did a thematic analysis of responses from those participants who answered a subsequent open question about reasons for their view. Research was done within a multidisciplinary team, including team members with clinical, legal, and ethical expertise, and lived experience of bipolar disorder. Ideas and methods associated with all these areas of expertise were used in the thematic analysis to gain insight into the thoughts of individuals with bipolar disorder about self-binding directives and associated issues. FINDINGS: Between Oct 23, 2017, and Dec 5, 2017, 932 individuals with a self-reported clinical diagnosis of bipolar disorder completed the internet survey, with 565 individuals (154 men, 400 women, 11 transgender or other), predominantly white British, providing free-text answers to the open question. 463 (82%) of the 565 participants endorsed self-binding directives, of whom 411 (89%) describing a determinate shift to distorted thinking and decision making when unwell as their key justification. Responses indicating ambivalence (37 [7%) of the 565 responses) were dominated by logistical concerns about the drafting and implementation of self-binding directives, whereas those who rejected self-binding directives (65 [12%] of the 565 responses) cited logistical concerns, validity of their thinking when unwell, and potential contravention of human rights. INTERPRETATION: This study is, to our knowledge, the first large study assessing the reasons why mental health service users might endorse or reject the use of self-binding directives. The findings provide empirical support for introducing self-binding directives into mental health services as well as advance decision-making practice and policy, and might help address enduring ethical concerns surrounding possible implementation of the directive while a person retains decision-making capacity. The opinions expressed here in responses given by multiple service users with bipolar disorder challenge a prominent view within international disability rights debates that involuntary treatment and recognition of impaired mental capacity constitute inherent human rights violations. FUNDING: The Wellcome Trust.
引用
- Gergel T, Das P, Owen G, et al. Reasons for endorsing or rejecting self-binding directives in bipolar disorder: a qualitative study of survey responses from UK service users. Lancet Psychiatry. 2021. PMID: 34022972. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(21)00115-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。