ICD-11与DSM-5精神障碍诊断要求的组织与类别层面比较
本文比较了ICD-11和DSM-5在精神障碍分类的组织结构和具体诊断标准上的异同。两系统组织架构大体相似,但ICD-11有19个类别不见于DSM-5,DSM-5有7个类别不见于ICD-11。对103个共有诊断实体的比较显示,20个(19.4%)有重大差异,42个(40.8%)有轻微定义差异,10个(9.7%)因DSM-5规定更细而有轻微差异,31个(30.1%)基本相同。
要点
- ICD-11与DSM-5组织架构相似,但互有对方没有的障碍类别。
- 共有诊断实体中约两成存在重大差异,四成有轻微定义差异。
- 差异主要源于两系统优先事项、用途及证据解读不同。
核心结论
- ICD-11与DSM-5比ICD-8与DSM-II以来任何时候都更接近。
- 两系统差异主要基于不同优先事项、用途及对证据的不同解读。
- 实质性分歧的方法允许对效度和效用进行实证比较,并可能推动领域进步。
研究设计与样本
- 本文评估WHO与APA在ICD-11和DSM-5开发期间协调努力的成功程度。
- 比较了ICD-11临床描述与诊断指南(CDDG)的“基本特征”部分与DSM-5标准集,涵盖103个共有诊断实体。
主要发现
- ICD-11有19个障碍类别不见于DSM-5,DSM-5有7个类别不见于ICD-11。
- 103个共有诊断实体中,20个(19.4%)有重大差异。
- 42个(40.8%)有轻微定义差异,10个(9.7%)因DSM-5规定更细而有轻微差异,31个(30.1%)基本相同。
关键数值与推荐
- 重大差异:20个诊断实体(19.4%)。
- 轻微定义差异:42个诊断实体(40.8%)。
- 因DSM-5更细化导致的轻微差异:10个诊断实体(9.7%)。
- 基本相同:31个诊断实体(30.1%)。
临床怎么用
- 为临床医生、研究者和政策制定者提供两系统在组织与障碍层面差异的指南。
- 帮助使用者在诊断实践中理解ICD-11与DSM-5的具体区别。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
In 2013, the American Psychiatric Association (APA) published the 5th edition of its Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). In 2019, the World Health Assembly approved the 11th revision of the International Classification of Diseases (ICD-11). It has often been suggested that the field would benefit from a single, unified classification of mental disorders, although the priorities and constituencies of the two sponsoring organizations are quite different. During the development of the ICD-11 and DSM-5, the World Health Organization (WHO) and the APA made efforts toward harmonizing the two systems, including the appointment of an ICD-DSM Harmonization Group. This paper evaluates the success of these harmonization efforts and provides a guide for practitioners, researchers and policy makers describing the differences between the two systems at both the organizational and the disorder level. The organization of the two classifications of mental disorders is substantially similar. There are nineteen ICD-11 disorder categories that do not appear in DSM-5, and seven DSM-5 disorder categories that do not appear in the ICD-11. We compared the Essential Features section of the ICD-11 Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines (CDDG) with the DSM-5 criteria sets for 103 diagnostic entities that appear in both systems. We rated 20 disorders (19.4%) as having major differences, 42 disorders (40.8%) as having minor definitional differences, 10 disorders (9.7%) as having minor differences due to greater degree of specification in DSM-5, and 31 disorders (30.1%) as essentially identical. Detailed descriptions of the major differences and some of the most important minor differences, with their rationale and related evidence, are provided. The ICD and DSM are now closer than at any time since the ICD-8 and DSM-II. Differences are largely based on the differing priorities and uses of the two diagnostic systems and on differing interpretations of the evidence. Substantively divergent approaches allow for empirical comparisons of validity and utility and can contribute to advances in the field.
引用
- First MB, Gaebel W, Maj M, et al. An organization- and category-level comparison of diagnostic requirements for mental disorders in ICD-11 and DSM-5. World Psychiatry. 2021. PMID: 33432742. doi:10.1002/wps.20825
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。