监狱内自伤的危险因素:系统综述与荟萃分析
自杀相关前因、当前任何精神科诊断及监狱特定环境因素与监狱内自伤关联最强,社会人口学与犯罪学因素关联较弱。
要点
- 单独监禁、违纪及狱内受害等监狱环境因素与自伤关联显著。
核心结论
- 监狱内自伤的危险因素跨越临床与监管多个领域,需要采取涵盖全监狱的综合预防策略。
- 预防策略应结合人群层面与针对性措施,并需精神卫生、社会照护与刑事司法服务多机构协作。
研究设计与样本
- 纳入从普通监狱人群取样的成人囚犯自伤研究并设无自伤对照组,排除定性或生态学研究、终生自伤测量及非普通监狱人群对照的研究。
- 对至少3个独立样本考察的危险因素采用随机效应模型合并比值比(OR),以Newcastle-Ottawa量表评估研究质量,方案注册于PROSPERO(CRD42018087915)。
临床怎么用
- 对入狱囚犯应系统筛查当前或近期自杀意念、终生自杀意念史及既往自伤史,以识别高危个体。
- 对存在当前精神科诊断(尤其重性抑郁和边缘型人格障碍)的囚犯应加强精神卫生评估与干预。
- 应审慎使用单独监禁,并关注违纪与狱内受害经历,将其纳入自伤风险评估。
- 预防自伤需精神卫生、社会照护与刑事司法多机构协作,并兼顾人群层面与针对性策略。
局限性
- 纳入研究为观察性设计,无法确立因果关系。
- 部分危险因素合并分析异质性较高(如单独监禁I2=98%、违纪I2=99%、重性抑郁I2=91%)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Self-harm is a leading cause of morbidity in prisoners. Although a wide range of risk factors for self-harm in prisoners has been identified, the strength and consistency of effect sizes is uncertain. We aimed to synthesise evidence and assess the risk factors associated with self-harm inside prison. METHODS: In this systematic review and meta-analysis, we searched four electronic databases (PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and PsycINFO) for observational studies on risk factors for self-harm in prisoners published from database inception to Oct 31, 2019, supplemented through correspondence with authors of studies. We included primary studies involving adults sampled from general prison populations who self-harmed in prison and a comparison group without self-harm in prison. We excluded studies with qualitative or ecological designs, those that reported on lifetime measures of self-harm or on selected samples of prisoners, and those with a comparison group that was not appropriate or not based on general prison populations. Data were extracted from the articles and requested from study authors. Our primary outcome was the risk of self-harm for risk factors in prisoners. We pooled effect sizes as odds ratios (OR) using random effects models for each risk factor examined in at least three distinct samples. We assessed study quality on the basis of the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale and examined between-study heterogeneity. The study protocol was registered with PROSPERO, CRD42018087915. FINDINGS: We identified 35 independent studies from 20 countries comprising a total of 663 735 prisoners, of whom 24 978 (3·8%) had self-harmed in prison. Across the 40 risk factors examined, the strongest associations with self-harm in prison were found for suicide-related antecedents, including current or recent suicidal ideation (OR 13·8, 95% CI 8·6-22·1; I2=49%), lifetime history of suicidal ideation (8·9, 6·1-13·0; I2=56%), and previous self-harm (6·6, 5·3-8·3; I2=55%). Any current psychiatric diagnosis was also strongly associated with self-harm (8·1, 7·0-9·4; I2=0%), particularly major depression (9·3, 2·9-29·5; I2=91%) and borderline personality disorder (9·2, 3·7-22·5; I2=81%). Prison-specific environmental risk factors for self-harm included solitary confinement (5·6, 2·7-11·6; I2=98%), disciplinary infractions (3·5, 1·2-9·7; I2=99%), and experiencing sexual or physical victimisation while in prison (3·2, 2·1-4·8; I2=44%). Sociodemographic (OR range 1·5-2·5) and criminological (1·8-2·3) factors were only modestly associated with self-harm in prison. We did not find clear evidence of publication bias. INTERPRETATION: The wide range of risk factors across clinical and custody-related domains underscores the need for a comprehensive, prison-wide approach towards preventing self-harm in prison. This approach should incorporate both population and targeted strategies, with multiagency collaboration between the services for mental health, social care, and criminal justice having a key role. FUNDING: Wellcome Trust.
引用
- Favril L, Yu R, Hawton K, et al. Risk factors for self-harm in prison: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet Psychiatry. 2020. PMID: 32711709. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(20)30190-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。