精神科诊断精神分裂症的血检:自我设限的探讨
本文探讨精神科医生是否因方法学、职业恐惧和概念问题而自我设限,阻碍了能完全替代临床诊断的完美血检的发展。作者以精神分裂症为例,提出完全替代临床诊断的血检通常不被期望,并预测只有提高诊断准确性但不取代临床诊断的血检才会成功。
要点
- 方法学问题如生物原因同质性假设阻碍有效亚组识别。
- 职业恐惧如访谈诊断专家技能重要性丧失。
- 概念问题如二元论思维模式。
核心结论
- 完全用血检替代临床诊断在临床医生中通常不被期望,多种因素维持当前诊断文化。
- 对血检诊断精神分裂症可能性的怀疑可能形成消极自我实现预言,阻碍科学努力。
- 只有提高诊断准确性但不取代临床诊断优先性的血检才会成功。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为评论文章,以精神分裂症为例讨论反对临床疾病类别自然化的因素。
主要发现
- 方法学问题如错误假设一个临床诊断下生物原因同质性,阻碍有效亚组识别。
- 职业恐惧如访谈诊断专家技能重要性丧失。
- 概念问题如二元论思维模式。
临床怎么用
- 未来需要新型专业技能,将各种生物变量与临床标准协同整合。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The naturalisation of mental disorders-ie, their translation into measurable and preferably molecular variables-has not progressed despite breath-taking discoveries in the neurosciences. We ask whether self-inflicted limits exist among psychiatrists that would prevent them from supporting an imaginary perfect blood test with diagnostic specificity, sensitivity, and validity, which was able to replace clinical diagnosis completely. Although relevant for many mental disorders, we use the clinical disease category schizophrenia here as an example to discuss factors that oppose the naturalisation of clinical disease categories. We defend the provocative position that a complete substitution of the clinical diagnosis by a blood test is generally not desired among clinicians because various factors perpetuate the current diagnostic culture. These are (1) methodological problems, such as a falsely presumed homogeneity of biological causes under the umbrella of one clinical diagnosis that prevents efficient subset identification, (2) professional fears, such as loss of importance of interview-diagnostic expert skills, and (3) conceptual problems, such as a dualistic mindset. We posit that doubts regarding the possibility of a blood test for diagnosing schizophrenia can subtly result in a negative self-fulfilling prophecy, discouraging serious scientific efforts to develop one. We give historical examples of how some of these problems have been solved in other medical disciplines. We predict that only blood tests that improve diagnostic accuracy but do not displace the primacy of clinical diagnosis will be successful. In the future, novel professional expertise for orchestrating various biological variables together with clinical criteria will be needed.
引用
- Korth C, Fangerau H. Blood tests to diagnose schizophrenia: self-imposed limits in psychiatry. Lancet Psychiatry. 2020. PMID: 32213327. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(20)30058-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。