因果推断方法在精神科流行病学中的应用综述
该综述讨论了精神科流行病学中因果推断方法的应用,将因果方法分为随机临床试验、自然实验和统计模型三类,指出RCT是金标准但存在泛化性局限,自然实验可控制已知和未知混杂,统计模型仅控制已知测量混杂,强调三角互证可增加因果推断可信度。
要点
- 因果方法包括RCT、自然实验和统计模型,前两者可控制已知和未知混杂,统计模型仅控制已知测量混杂。
- RCT作为金标准存在泛化性局限,且许多精神科流行病学关键问题因伦理原因无法用RCT回答。
- 三角互证即对同一问题应用不同因果推断方法,可增加因果结论的可信度。
核心结论
- 因果推断对病因模型和预防工作很重要,不能仅凭RCT才能解决因果问题,各方法各有优劣,应避免过度因果声称和因果不可知的极端观点,三角互证可提高因果推断可信度。
研究设计与样本
- 综述,检索范围未报告。
主要发现
- 因果方法可分为随机临床试验、自然实验和统计模型,前两者可控制已知和未知混杂,统计方法仅控制已知和测量混杂。
- RCT作为金标准存在重要局限性,尤其泛化性方面,且许多精神科流行病学关键问题因伦理原因无法用RCT回答。
- 综述举例讨论了满足as-if随机化假设的方法、工具变量、前后设计、回归断点设计和共相对设计,每种方法均有优势和局限。
- 在统计方法中,综述考察了倾向评分和边际模型,二者最适合应用于风险因素暴露有强预测因子的样本。
临床怎么用
- 在精神科流行病学研究中,应根据问题选择因果推断方法,并认识各方法的假设与局限,避免仅依赖RCT或仅依赖统计模型。
- 对同一因果问题可应用不同方法进行三角互证,以提高因果结论的可信度。
局限性
- 原文未报告综述的检索范围与纳入标准。
- 各因果推断方法的as-if随机化合理性和泛化性存在局限,原文未报告具体数值评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Associations between putative risk factors and psychiatric and substance use disorders are widespread in the literature. Basing prevention efforts on such findings is hazardous. Applying causal inference methods, while challenging, is central to developing realistic and potentially actionable etiologic models for psychopathology. OBSERVATIONS: Causal methods can be divided into randomized clinical trials (RCTs), natural experiments, and statistical models. The first 2 approaches can potentially control for both known and unknown confounders, while statistical methods control only for known and measured confounders. The criterion standard, RCTs, can have important limitations, especially regarding generalizability. Furthermore, for ethical reasons, many critical questions in psychiatric epidemiology cannot be addressed by RCTs. We review, with examples, methods that try to meet as-if randomization assumptions, use instrumental variables, or use pre-post designs, regression discontinuity designs, or co-relative designs. Each method has strengths and limitations, especially the plausibility of as-if randomization and generalizability. Of the large family of statistical methods for causal inference, we examine propensity scoring and marginal models, which are best applied to samples with strong predictors of risk factor exposure. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Causal inference is important because it informs etiologic models and prevention efforts. The view that causation can be definitively resolved only with RCTs and that no other method can provide potentially useful inferences is simplistic. Rather, each method has varying strengths and limitations. We need to avoid the extremes of overzealous causal claims and the cynical view that potential causal information is unattainable when RCTs are infeasible. Triangulation, which applies different methods for elucidating causal inferences to address to the same question, may increase confidence in the resulting causal claims.
引用
- Ohlsson H, Kendler KS. Applying Causal Inference Methods in Psychiatric Epidemiology: A Review. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020. PMID: 31825494. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2019.3758
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。