文献速递焦虑、强迫与应激相关障碍

CBT对惊恐障碍偏倚语义网络的影响:多中心fMRI语义启动研究

Effect of CBT on Biased Semantic Network in Panic Disorder: A Multicenter fMRI Study Using Semantic Priming.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Psychiatry · 2019-12-16

该多中心fMRI研究采用惊恐障碍特异性自动语义启动范式,比较118例患者与150名健康对照在基线及42例患者与52名对照暴露式CBT后的行为与神经相关物。患者基线对惊恐触发/症状词对评分相关性和负效价更高、词汇判断更快,伴颞叶与岛叶激活抑制及前后扣带回激活增强;CBT后临床改善且相关性与负效价评分降低、前扣带回激活减弱。

要点

  • 惊恐障碍患者存在偏倚的惊恐相关语义网络,表现为行为启动效应增强和特定脑区激活异常。
  • 暴露式CBT后患者临床改善,惊恐触发/症状词对的相关性与负效价评分降低。
  • CBT后前扣带回对惊恐相关关联加工的激活减弱,可能为未来治疗干预的潜在机制。

核心结论

  • 研究结果支持惊恐障碍存在偏倚语义网络,且该网络在CBT后趋于正常化。
  • 前扣带回对惊恐相关关联加工的激活减弱,为未来治疗干预提供了潜在机制。

研究设计与样本

  • 多中心功能性磁共振成像研究,采用惊恐障碍特异性自动语义启动范式。
  • 基线比较118例惊恐障碍患者与150名健康对照,CBT后比较42例患者与52名对照。
  • 神经相关物分析比较基线(患者)或T1(对照)的103对匹配患者与对照,以及治疗后或T2的39对。

主要发现

  • 基线或T1时,患者对惊恐触发/惊恐症状词对的相关性评分和负效价评分均高于健康对照。
  • 患者对惊恐触发词后呈现的惊恐症状词进行词汇判断更快。
  • 患者的惊恐启动效应(相较对照)反映为左右颞叶皮质和岛叶激活抑制,以及后扣带回和前扣带回激活增强。
  • CBT后患者组临床显著改善,同时惊恐触发/惊恐症状词对的相关性评分和负效价评分降低。
  • CBT后前扣带回对惊恐触发/惊恐症状词对加工的激活减弱。

关键数值与推荐

  • 研究采用暴露式CBT。
  • 行为学指标包括惊恐触发/惊恐症状词对的相关性评分、负效价评分及词汇判断反应时。
  • 神经指标为左右颞叶皮质、岛叶、后扣带回和前扣带回激活。

临床怎么用

  • 可将惊恐触发/症状词对的语义关联偏倚作为评估惊恐障碍认知网络的指标。
  • 暴露式CBT可降低惊恐相关语义关联的负效价与相关性评分并调节前扣带回激活。
  • 前扣带回激活减弱可作为未来治疗干预开发的潜在靶点。

局限性

  • CBT后完成fMRI的患者样本量较基线减少(42例患者与52名对照)。
  • 神经相关物分析仅纳入匹配的患者与对照对(基线103对,治疗后39对)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) has been hypothesized to act by reducing the pathologically enhanced semantic, anxiety-related associations of patients with panic disorder. This study investigated the effects of CBT on the behavioral and neural correlates of the panic-related semantic network in patients with panic disorder. METHODS: An automatic semantic priming paradigm specifically tailored for panic disorder, in which panic symptoms (e.g., "dizziness") were primed by panic triggers (e.g., "elevator") compared with neutral words (e.g., "bottle"), was performed during functional MRI scanning with 118 patients with panic disorder (compared with 150 healthy control subjects) before and 42 patients (compared with 52 healthy control subjects) after an exposure-based CBT. Neural correlates were investigated by comparing 103 pairs of matched patients and control subjects at the baseline (for patients) or T1 (for control subjects) assessment and 39 pairs at the posttreatment or T2 assessment. RESULTS: At baseline or T1, patients rated panic-trigger/panic-symptom word pairs with higher relatedness and higher negative valence compared with healthy control subjects. Patients made faster lexical decisions to the panic-symptom words when they were preceded by panic-trigger words. This panic-priming effect in patients (compared with control subjects) was reflected in suppressed neural activation in the left and right temporal cortices and insulae and enhanced activation in the posterior and anterior cingulate cortices. After CBT, significant clinical improvements in the patient group were observed along with a reduction in relatedness and negative valence rating and attenuation of neural activation in the anterior cingulate cortex for processing of panic-trigger/panic-symptom word pairs. CONCLUSIONS: The findings support a biased semantic network in panic disorder, which is normalized after CBT. Attenuation of anterior cingulate cortex activation for processing of panic-related associations provides a potential mechanism for future therapeutic interventions.

来源:Am J Psychiatry,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Yang Y, Lueken U, Richter J, et al. Effect of CBT on Biased Semantic Network in Panic Disorder: A Multicenter fMRI Study Using Semantic Priming. Am J Psychiatry. 2019. PMID: 31838872. doi:10.1176/appi.ajp.2019.19020202

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。