租金补贴与心理健康支持对无家可归精神疾病患者的6年长期效果:At Home/Chez Soi随机对照试验扩展研究
该研究为加拿大At Home/Chez Soi随机对照试验的多伦多站点6年扩展研究,纳入575名无家可归且患有严重精神障碍的成人,比较Housing First(租金补贴+心理健康支持)与常规治疗。结果显示,Housing First组稳定住房天数在所有时间点均显著高于常规治疗组,高支持需求者受益更大,但效应随时间有所减弱。
要点
- Housing First干预(租金补贴+支持服务)对无家可归精神疾病患者住房稳定性有持续6年的正向效果。
核心结论
- 租金补贴与心理健康支持服务对大型资源丰富城市中心的无家可归精神疾病成人住房稳定性具有持久正向效果。
- 该干预对高支持需求个体的影响大于中等支持需求个体。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为在加拿大多伦多进行的随机对照试验扩展研究,参与者为年龄≥18岁、患有严重精神障碍(伴或不伴物质使用障碍)的无家可归成人。
- 第一阶段按心理健康支持需求水平(高 vs 中等)分层,采用自适应随机化按1:1分配至Housing First联合积极社区治疗(HF-ACT)、Housing First联合强化个案管理(HF-ICM)或常规治疗(TAU);中等需求者进一步按种族民族身份分层。
- 第一阶段参与者可自愿加入扩展研究(第二阶段);主要结局为改良意向治疗人群中每年稳定住房天数率,采用多水平多重插补处理缺失数据。
- 第一阶段于2009年10月1日至2013年3月31日纳入575名参与者(高支持需求197人,中等支持需求378人);第二阶段于2014年1月1日至2017年3月31日纳入414名(81%)第一阶段参与者。
主要发现
- HF-ACT组和HF-ICM或HF-ER-ICM组在所有时间点的稳定住房天数均显著高于TAU组。
临床怎么用
- 对于无家可归且患有严重精神障碍的成人,提供租金补贴联合心理健康支持服务可长期改善住房稳定性。
- 高支持需求个体从Housing First干预中获得的住房稳定性收益更大,应优先保障其支持服务强度。
局限性
- 研究参与者与研究人员未对分组设盲。
- 研究仅在多伦多一个站点进行扩展,外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Housing First is increasingly implemented for homeless adults with mental illness in large urban centres, but little is known about its long-term effectiveness. The At Home/Chez Soi randomised controlled trial done in five cities in Canada showed that Housing First improved housing stability and other select health outcomes. We extended the At Home/Chez Soi trial at the Toronto site to evaluate the long-term effects of the Housing First intervention on housing and health outcomes of homeless adults with mental illness over 6 years. METHODS: The At Home/Chez Soi Toronto study was a randomised, controlled trial done in Toronto (ON, Canada). Here, we present the results of an extension study done at the same site. Participants were homeless adults (aged ≥18 years) with a serious mental disorder with or without co-occurring substance use disorder. In phase 1, participants were stratified by level of need for mental health support services (high vs moderate), and randomly assigned (1:1) using adaptive randomisation procedures to Housing First with assertive community treatment (HF-ACT), Housing First with intensive case management (HF-ICM), or to treatment as usual (TAU). Participants with moderate support needs were further stratified by ethnoracial status. Considering the nature of the Housing First intervention, study participants and study personnel were not masked to group assignment. Phase 1 participants could choose to enrol in the extension study (phase 2). The primary outcome was the rate of days stably housed per year analysed in the modified intention-to-treat population, which included all randomly assigned participants who had at least one assessment for the primary outcome. Participants contributed data to the study up to the point of their last interview. Multilevel multiple imputation was used to handle missing data. The trial was registered with ISRCTN, ISRCTN42520374. FINDINGS: Between Oct 1, 2009, and March 31, 2013, 575 individuals participated in phase 1 of the Toronto Site At Home/Chez Soi study (197 [34%] participants with high support needs and 378 [66%] with moderate support needs). Of the 378 participants with moderate support needs, 204 were randomly assigned to receive the HF intervention with ICM or with ethnoracial-specific ICM services (HF-ER-ICM; HF-ICM or HF-ER-ICM groups) and 174 were randomly assigned to TAU. Of the 197 participants with high support needs, 97 were randomly assigned to receive the HF intervention with ACT (HF-ACT treatment group) and 100 were randomly assigned to TAU group. Between Jan 1, 2014, and March 31, 2017, 414 (81%) of 575 phase 1 participants participated in the extended phase 2 study. The median duration of follow-up was 5·4 years (IQR 2·1-5·9). Among phase 2 participants, 141 had high support needs (79 participants in the HF-ACT group; 62 participants in the TAU group), and 273 had moderate support needs (160 participants in the HF-ICM or HF-ER-ICM group; 113 participants in the TAU group). 187 high support needs participants (93 participants in the HF-ACT group, 94 participants in the TAU group), and 361 moderate support needs participants (201 participants in the HF-ICM or HF-ER-ICM group, 160 participants in the TAU group) were included in the modified intention-to-treat analysis for the primary outcome. The number of days spent stably housed was significantly higher among participants in the HF-ACT and HR-ICM or HF-ER-ICM groups than participants in the TAU groups at all timepoints. For participants with moderate support needs, the rate ratio (RR) of days stably housed in the Housing First group, compared with TAU, was 2·40 (95% CI 2·03-2·83) in year 1, which decreased to 1·13 (1·01-1·26) in year 6. The RR of days stably housed for participants with high support needs, compared with TAU, was 3·02 (2·43-3·75) in year 1 and 1·42 (1·19-1·69) in year 6. In year 6, high support needs participants in the Housing First group spent 85·51% of days stably housed compared with 60·33% for the TAU group, and moderate needs participants in the Housing First group spent 88·16% of days stably housed compared with 78·22% for the TAU group. INTERPRETATION: Rent supplements and mental health support services had an enduring positive effect on housing stability for homeless adults with mental illness in a large, resource-rich urban centre, with a larger impact on individuals with high support needs than moderate support needs. FUNDING: Mental Health Commission of Canada, Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, and the Canadian Institute of Health Research.
引用
- Stergiopoulos V, Mejia-Lancheros C, Nisenbaum R, et al. Long-term effects of rent supplements and mental health support services on housing and health outcomes of homeless adults with mental illness: extension study of the At Home/Chez Soi randomised controlled trial. Lancet Psychiatry. 2019. PMID: 31601530. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(19)30371-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。