儿童青少年急性焦虑障碍不同心理治疗类型与可接受性:网络Meta分析
该网络Meta分析纳入101项随机临床试验共6625名儿童青少年,比较11种心理治疗与4种对照条件。结果显示多数心理治疗优于等待名单,但仅团体认知行为治疗(CBT)在治疗后显著优于其他心理治疗及所有对照条件;阅读疗法CBT的全因脱落率较高。
要点
- 团体CBT是儿童青少年焦虑障碍更合适的心理治疗选择。
- 多数心理治疗优于等待名单,但仅团体CBT显著优于其他心理治疗和所有对照。
- 阅读疗法CBT的全因脱落率显著高于部分心理治疗和对照条件。
核心结论
- 基于该网络Meta分析,团体CBT是儿童青少年焦虑障碍更合适的心理治疗选择,其他心理治疗类型和递送方式可作为替代选项。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为贝叶斯网络Meta分析,检索PubMed等数据库及试验注册库至2017年11月30日,纳入比较结构化心理治疗与另一心理治疗或对照条件的随机临床试验。
- 共纳入101项独特试验、6625名独特参与者,比较11种不同心理治疗与4种特定对照条件;由四名研究者独立提取数据并评估质量。
主要发现
- 对于疗效,多数心理治疗在治疗后显著优于等待名单条件(SMD范围-1.43至-0.61),在最长期随访时也显著优于等待名单(SMD范围-1.84至-1.64)。
- 仅团体CBT在治疗后显著优于其他心理治疗及所有对照条件。
- 对于可接受性,阅读疗法CBT的全因脱落显著多于部分心理治疗和对照条件(OR范围2.48-9.32)。
- 在生活质量和功能改善方面,以不同方式递送的CBT显著优于心理安慰剂和等待名单条件(SMD范围0.73至1.99)。
- 大多数比较的证据确定性被评为低或极低。
关键数值与推荐
- 疗效以焦虑症状变化衡量,可接受性以全因脱落衡量,同时测量生活质量和功能改善。
- 证据确定性采用GRADE框架评估,大多数比较为低或极低确定性。
临床怎么用
- 临床可优先考虑团体CBT作为儿童青少年焦虑障碍的心理治疗方案。
- 其他心理治疗类型和递送方式可作为替代选项,但需注意阅读疗法CBT的脱落风险较高。
局限性
- 大多数比较的证据确定性被评为低或极低。
- 需要进一步研究探索特定焦虑障碍、障碍特异性心理治疗及治疗效应的调节因素。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Anxiety disorders are common in children and adolescents, and uncertainty remains regarding the optimal strategy of psychotherapies in this population. OBJECTIVE: To compare and rank the different types of psychotherapies and the different ways of delivering psychological treatments for anxiety disorders in children and adolescents. DATA SOURCES: PubMed, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, EMBASE, PsycINFO, Web of Science, CINAHL (Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature), ProQuest Dissertations, LILACS (Literatura Latino Americana em Ciências da Saúde), international trial registers, and US Food and Drug Administration reports were searched from inception to November 30, 2017. STUDY SELECTION: Randomized clinical trials that compared any structured psychotherapy with another psychotherapy or a control condition for anxiety disorders in children and adolescents were selected. DATA EXTRACTION AND SYNTHESIS: Four researchers independently performed data extraction and quality assessment. Pairwise meta-analyses and Bayesian network meta-analysis within the random-effects model were used to synthesize data. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES: Efficacy (change in anxiety symptoms) posttreatment and at follow-up, acceptability (all-cause discontinuation), and quality of life and functional improvement were measured. The certainty of evidence was assessed using the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation framework. RESULTS: A total of 101 unique trials including 6625 unique participants compared 11 different psychotherapies with 4 specific control conditions. The certainty of evidence was rated as low or very low for most comparisons. For efficacy, most psychotherapies were significantly more effective than the wait list condition posttreatment (standardized mean difference [SMD], -1.43 to -0.61) and at the longest follow-up (SMD, -1.84 to -1.64). However, only group cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) was significantly more effective than the other psychotherapies and all control conditions posttreatment. For acceptability, bibliotherapy CBT had significantly more all-cause discontinuations than some psychotherapies and control conditions (range of odds ratios, 2.48-9.32). In terms of quality of life and functional improvement, CBT (delivered in different ways) was significantly beneficial compared with psychological placebo and the wait list condition (SMDs, 0.73 to 1.99). CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Group CBT would be the more appropriate choice of psychotherapy for anxiety disorders in children and adolescents, based on these findings. Other types of psychotherapies and different ways of delivering psychological treatment can be alternative options. Further research is needed to explore specific anxiety disorders, disorder-specific psychotherapy, and moderators of treatment effect. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO Identifier: CRD42015016283.
引用
- Zhou X, Zhang Y, Furukawa TA, et al. Different Types and Acceptability of Psychotherapies for Acute Anxiety Disorders in Children and Adolescents: A Network Meta-analysis. JAMA Psychiatry. 2019. PMID: 30383099. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2018.3070
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。