精神障碍严重程度的界定与功能损害的独立性
本文综述了精神障碍严重程度在研究和诊断系统中的界定方式,重点分析抑郁和人格障碍。发现DSM-5对不同程度障碍采用不同定义,抑郁严重度多用症状量表评分,人格障碍则常与功能损害挂钩。作者主张症状定义的障碍其严重度应与功能损害分开界定。
要点
- DSM-5对不同精神障碍的严重程度定义方式不一致。
- 抑郁严重度多按症状量表评分界定,人格障碍严重度常与功能损害关联。
- 症状定义障碍的严重度应独立于功能损害,因功能受外在因素影响。
核心结论
- 精神障碍严重程度的界定在研究和诊断系统中差异很大,症状定义的障碍其严重度应与功能损害独立界定。
研究设计与样本
- 综述类文章,检索并汇总研究和当代精神障碍诊断系统(重点DSM-5)中对严重程度的界定方式,聚焦抑郁和人格障碍。
主要发现
- DSM-5以不同方式定义不同障碍的严重程度。
- 抑郁严重度主要按症状量表评分定义,人格障碍严重度常与功能损害挂钩。
- 症状定义障碍的功能影响取决于自我效能、韧性、应对能力、社会支持、文化社会期望及角色责任等障碍外因素。
关键数值与推荐
- 抑郁严重度主要依据症状评定量表得分界定,人格障碍严重度常与功能损害关联。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估精神障碍严重度时,对症状定义的障碍应考虑将症状严重度与功能损害分开评定。
- 严重度影响护理级别决策和因精神残疾申请政府援助的判断。
局限性
- 本文为综述,未报告原始研究样本量、效应值或置信区间等定量数据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The issue of the severity of psychiatric disorders has great clinical importance. For example, severity influences decisions about level of care, and affects decisions to seek government assistance due to psychiatric disability. Controversy exists as to the efficacy of antidepressants across the spectrum of depression severity, and whether patients with severe depression should be preferentially treated with medication rather than psychotherapy. Measures of severity are used to evaluate outcome in treatment studies and may be used as meaningful endpoints in clinical practice. But, what does it mean to say that someone has a severe illness? Does severity refer to the number of symptoms a patient is experiencing? To the intensity of the symptoms? To symptom frequency or persistence? To the impact of symptoms on functioning or on quality of life? To the likelihood of the illness resulting in permanent disability or death? Putting aside the issue of how severity should be operationalized, another consideration is whether severity should be conceptualized similarly for all illnesses or be disorder specific. In this paper, we examine how severity is characterized in research and contemporary psychiatric diagnostic systems, with a special focus on depression and personality disorders. Our review shows that the DSM-5 has defined the severity of various disorders in different ways, and that researchers have adopted a myriad of ways of defining severity for both depression and personality disorders, although the severity of the former was predominantly defined according to scores on symptom rating scales, whereas the severity of the latter was often linked with impairments in functioning. Because the functional impact of symptom-defined disorders depends on factors extrinsic to those disorders, such as self-efficacy, resilience, coping ability, social support, cultural and social expectations, as well as the responsibilities related to one's primary role function and the availability of others to assume those responsibilities, we argue that the severity of such disorders should be defined independently from functional impairment.
引用
- Zimmerman M, Morgan TA, Stanton K, et al. The severity of psychiatric disorders. World Psychiatry. 2018. PMID: 30192110. doi:10.1002/wps.20569
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。