激励可提升多种精神病理构念下的模型化控制
研究招募839名在线非患者参与者,完成跨诊断自评量表并执行序列决策任务,同时操纵激励大小,拟合双控制器强化学习模型计算模型化控制。结果显示多数构念严重度与模型化控制下降相关,但无构念阻碍大激励提升模型化控制,感觉寻求和焦虑抑郁因子高分者激励效应更大。
要点
- 大激励提升模型化控制不受任何构念严重度阻碍。
- 感觉寻求和焦虑抑郁因子越高,激励对模型化控制的提升越大。
- 多数构念严重度越高模型化控制越低,但社交退缩因子呈正相关。
核心结论
- 模型化控制可独立于多数构念严重度被激励可靠提升,激励或可作为跨症状严重度提升模型化控制的干预手段。
研究设计与样本
- 在线招募839名非患者参与者,完成跨诊断自评量表及序列决策任务,并操纵激励大小,拟合双控制器强化学习模型分别计算小激励和大激励下的模型化控制。
主要发现
- 无任何构念与「大激励未能提升模型化控制」相关。
- 感觉寻求特质和焦虑抑郁因子得分越高,激励效应越大,即模型化控制增幅更大。
- 许多构念严重度越高模型化控制越低,但社交退缩因子与模型化控制正相关。
- 酒精使用和社交焦虑与模型化控制无关。
临床怎么用
- 对多数症状和特质严重度,可通过提供足够激励来提升模型化控制。
- 对高感觉寻求或高焦虑抑郁者,激励可能更有效提升模型化控制。
局限性
- 研究对象为非患者在线样本,结果外推至临床人群需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Human decision making exhibits a mixture of model-based and model-free control. Recent evidence indicates that arbitration between these two modes of control ("metacontrol") is based on their relative costs and benefits. While model-based control may increase accuracy, it requires greater computational resources, so people invoke model-based control only when potential rewards exceed those of model-free control. We used a sequential decision task, while concurrently manipulating performance incentives, to ask if symptoms and traits of psychopathology decrease or increase model-based control in response to incentives. METHODS: We recruited a nonpatient population of 839 online participants using Amazon Mechanical Turk who completed transdiagnostic self-report measures encompassing symptoms, traits, and factors. We fit a dual-controller reinforcement learning model and obtained a computational measure of model-based control separately for small incentives and large incentives. RESULTS: None of the constructs were related to a failure of large incentives to boost model-based control. In fact, for the sensation seeking trait and anxious-depression factor, higher scores were associated with a larger incentive effect, whereby greater levels of these constructs were associated with larger increases in model-based control. Many constructs showed decreases in model-based control as a function of severity, but a social withdrawal factor was positively correlated; alcohol use and social anxiety were unrelated to model-based control. CONCLUSIONS: Our results demonstrate that model-based control can reliably be improved independent of construct severity for most measures. This suggests that incentives may be a useful intervention for boosting model-based control across a range of symptom and trait severity.
引用
- Patzelt EH, Kool W, Millner AJ, et al. Incentives Boost Model-Based Control Across a Range of Severity on Several Psychiatric Constructs. Biol Psychiatry. 2018. PMID: 30077331. doi:10.1016/j.biopsych.2018.06.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。