持续性精神病性体验的评估与临床相关性的实验研究
UNIQUE研究比较了临床精神病患者、无医疗需求但持续存在精神病性体验者及无此体验对照共259人,通过深度访谈和实验任务评估其对精神病性体验的评估方式。结果显示临床组更倾向于偏执、个人化解释,且评价更负面、危险、异常和不可控;实验诱发的异常体验中临床组威胁性评估更高,支持认知模型。
要点
- 临床组比非临床组更常对精神病性体验作偏执、个人化解释,更少正常化或超自然解释。
- 临床组评价体验更负面、危险、异常且不可控,但一般外归因无组间差异。
- 实验诱发的异常体验中,临床组威胁性评估更高,非临床组与对照组无差异。
核心结论
- 精神病性体验的评估方式在有医疗需求者与无需求者间存在差异,支持认知模型。
- 缺乏偏执和威胁性评估可能保护持续性精神病性体验不发展为临床相关。
研究设计与样本
- UNIQUE实验研究,纳入259名参与者:临床组84例确诊精神病性障碍患者,非临床组92名无医疗需求但持续存在精神病性体验的成人,对照组83名无精神病性体验者。
- 通过深度访谈评估非临床组和临床组对精神病性体验的评估,并比较所有组对三种实验任务诱发的异常体验的评估。
主要发现
- 显著性、痛苦、个人相关性、整体威胁及将诱发体验纳入自身精神病性体验的评分模式类似。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估可关注患者对精神病性体验的偏执、威胁性、负面和不可控解释,作为认知干预靶点。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cognitive models of psychosis propose that appraisals (ie, the interpretation and meaning attributed to experiences) are central to the transition from anomalous experiences to psychotic symptoms. In the Unusual Experiences Enquiry (UNIQUE) study, we investigated the role of appraisals by comparing individuals with persistent psychotic experiences without a need for care with patients and people without psychotic experiences. METHOD: Eligible participants were patients with diagnosed psychotic disorders (clinical group) and adults in the general population with persistent psychotic experiences (non-clinical group) and without psychotic experiences (controls). The appraisals of psychotic experiences among people in the non-clinical and clinical groups were assessed by an in-depth interview, and appraisals of anomalous experiences induced by three experimental tasks were compared between all groups. FINDINGS: We recruited 259 participants, 84 in the clinical group, 92 in the non-clinical group, and 83 controls. The clinical group was more likely than the non-clinical group to display paranoid, personalising interpretations of their psychotic experiences (p<0·008; p values are Sidak adjusted to account for multiple testing) and less likely to have normalising (p<0·008) and supernatural (p=0·039) explanations. The clinical group also appraised their psychotic experiences as being more negative, dangerous, and abnormal and less controllable than the non-clinical group (all p<0·005), but groups did not differ for attributions of general externality (p=0·44). For experimentally induced anomalous experiences, the clinical group endorsed more threatening appraisals on all tasks than the non-clinical group (p<0·003), who did not differ from the control group (p=0·07-0·6). The pattern was similar for ratings of salience, distress, personal relevance, global threat, and incorporation of the induced experiences into participants' own psychotic experiences. INTERPRETATION: We provide robust evidence that the way psychotic experiences are appraised differs between individuals with and without a need for care, supporting cognitive models of psychosis. Specifically, the absence of paranoid and threatening appraisals might protect against persistent psychotic experiences becoming clinically relevant. FUNDING: UK Medical Research Council.
引用
- Peters E, Ward T, Jackson M, et al. Clinical relevance of appraisals of persistent psychotic experiences in people with and without a need for care: an experimental study. Lancet Psychiatry. 2017. PMID: 29179936. doi:10.1016/S2215-0366(17)30409-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。