对「超高危」与「转化」范式的批判
本文批判UHR/CHR研究范式,认为该样本高度异质,实为常见精神障碍伴精神病性体验者;「风险」与「转化」概念定义狭窄、转化率因样本富集策略而虚高且未排除假阳性,与功能结局无关。建议以公共卫生视角替代低效的高危策略。
要点
- UHR/CHR样本高度异质,实为常见精神障碍伴精神病性体验者。
- 转化率受样本富集策略影响而虚高,未排除精神病性体验自然波动的假阳性。
- 转化与功能结局缺乏相关性,应关注全范围个体特异性精神病理。
核心结论
- 用「精神分裂」棱镜观察年轻人多维精神病理的早期状态既不实用也不有效。
- UHR/CHR研究中的「风险」与「转化」概念定义狭窄,转化率因样本富集策略而虚高。
- 与「转化」相关的生物学关联可能为假阳性发现。
- 建议以公共卫生视角替代相对低效的医学高危策略。
研究设计与样本
- 本文为对UHR/CHR文献的批判性综述,未报告系统检索范围与样本量。
主要发现
- UHR/CHR样本高度异质,代表被诊断为常见精神障碍并伴一定程度精神病性体验的个体。
- 流行病学研究显示精神病性体验是多维精神病理严重度的标志,驱动不良结局。
- UHR/CHR研究中的「风险」与「转化」基于阳性精神病性现象定义,忽略基线多维精神病理差异。
- 「转化」主要随样本富集策略变化,而非UHR/CHR「标准」本身。
- 大量UHR/CHR干预研究聚焦于「转化」结局,其与功能结局缺乏相关性。
关键数值与推荐
- UHR/CHR研究中的「风险」与「转化」在同一维度量表上测量,却用于产生人为的诊断转换。
临床怎么用
- 应考虑所有因心理健康问题求助的年轻人的全范围个体特异性精神病理,而非仅监测精神病性维度。
- 可采用公共卫生视角,聚焦改善对低污名、高希望、小规模且面向青年的环境的可及性。
局限性
- 本文为批判性综述,未报告系统检索策略、纳入研究数量及样本特征。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
The transdiagnostic expression of psychotic experiences in common mental disorder (anxiety/depression/substance use disorder) is associated with a poorer prognosis, and a small minority of people may indeed develop a clinical picture that meets criteria for schizophrenia. However, it appears neither useful nor valid to observe early states of multidimensional psychopathology in young people through the "schizo"-prism, and apply misleadingly simple, unnecessary and inefficient binary concepts of "risk" and "transition". A review of the "ultra-high risk" (UHR) or "clinical high risk" (CHR) literature indicates that UHR/CHR samples are highly heterogeneous and represent individuals diagnosed with common mental disorder (anxiety/depression/substance use disorder) and a degree of psychotic experiences. Epidemiological research has shown that psychotic experiences are a (possibly non-causal) marker of the severity of multidimensional psychopathology, driving poor outcome, yet notions of "risk" and "transition" in UHR/CHR research are restrictively defined on the basis of positive psychotic phenomena alone, ignoring how baseline differences in multidimensional psychopathology may differentially impact course and outcome. The concepts of "risk" and "transition" in UHR/CHR research are measured on the same dimensional scale, yet are used to produce artificial diagnostic shifts. In fact, "transition" in UHR/CHR research occurs mainly as a function of variable sample enrichment strategies rather than the UHR/CHR "criteria" themselves. Furthermore, transition rates in UHR/CHR research are inflated as they do not exclude false positives associated with the natural fluctuation of dimensional expression of psychosis. Biological associations with "transition" thus likely represent false positive findings, as was the initial claim of strong effects of omega-3 polyunsatured fatty acids in UHR samples. A large body of UHR/CHR intervention research has focused on the questionable outcome of "transition", which shows lack of correlation with functional outcome. It may be more productive to consider the full range of person-specific psychopathology in all young individuals who seek help for mental health problems, instead of "policing" youngsters for the transdiagnostic dimension of psychosis. Instead of the relatively inefficient medical high-risk approach, a public health perspective, focusing on improved access to a low-stigma, high-hope, small scale and youth-specific environment with acceptable language and interventions may represent a more useful and efficient strategy.
引用
- van Os J, Guloksuz S. A critique of the "ultra-high risk" and "transition" paradigm. World Psychiatry. 2017. PMID: 28498576. doi:10.1002/wps.20423
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。