双相障碍中的激活现象:系统综述
本系统综述纳入1970年至2016年间MEDLINE、PsycINFO、EMBASE、CINAHL和PubMed数据库的56项研究,评估双相障碍中激活这一临床现象。研究提示心境与激活为双相障碍的不同维度,双相障碍患者在心境正常和抑郁期活动平均水平低于健康对照,而躁狂可能更多表现为激活的稳定性、变异性、可预测性或复杂性差异而非活动平均水平差异。总体证据在数据局限内广泛支持DSM-5将激活提升为双相障碍A类症状。
要点
- 心境与激活是双相障碍中相对独立的维度。
- 双相障碍患者心境正常和抑郁期活动平均水平低于健康对照和其他对照人群。
- 躁狂可能更多表现为激活的稳定性、变异性、可预测性或复杂性差异而非活动平均水平差异。
核心结论
- 在数据局限内,现有证据广泛支持DSM-5将激活提升为双相障碍的A类症状。
- 尽管激活在双相障碍中的重要性已被认识超过一个世纪,本综述提示这一关键构念研究不足,应成为更系统高质量研究的主题。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述检索MEDLINE、PsycINFO、EMBASE、CINAHL和PubMed数据库1970年1月1日至2016年9月30日的文献。
- 从可能的3284条引文中纳入56项研究,包括29项双相障碍因子结构分析、3项实验采样或生态瞬时评估的活动数据研究、20项活动记录仪研究和4项实验室研究。
- 通过手工检索参考文献列表、专业期刊、网站、已发表会议论文集和学位论文摘要并联系其他研究者,确保纳入灰色文献及适当情况下的额外分析和原始数据。
- 使用美国国立卫生研究院质量评估工具进行质量评估。
主要发现
- 最稳健的发现是双相障碍患者在心境正常和抑郁期活动平均水平低于健康对照和其他对照人群(11项研究)。
- 7项生态和实验室研究显示双相障碍患者相比他人行为模式组织性或可预测性较差且习惯化相对缺乏。
- 因子分析研究提供相当一致的证据表明心境和激活代表双相障碍的不同维度。
临床怎么用
- 临床评估双相障碍时应将激活作为独立于心境的重要维度加以关注。
- 除活动平均水平外,还应关注激活的稳定性、变异性、可预测性和复杂性等动态特征。
局限性
- 结论受数据局限性约束,综述指出激活这一关键构念研究不足,需更多系统高质量研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
IMPORTANCE: Increased activity and energy alongside mood change are identified in the DSM-5 as cardinal symptoms of mania and hypomania. A wide range of existing research suggests that this revision may be valid, but systematic integration of the evidence has not been reported. The term activation is understood as emerging from underlying physiological change and having objective (observable motor activity) and related subjective (energy) levels. OBJECTIVES: To systematically review studies of the clinical phenomenon of activation in bipolar disorder, to determine whether activation is statistically abnormal in bipolar disorder and demonstrably distinct from mood, and to identify any significant between- and within-individual differences in the dynamics of activation. EVIDENCE REVIEW: This systematic review of MEDLINE, PsycINFO, EMBASE, CINAHL, and PubMed databases from January 1, 1970, until September 30, 2016, identified 56 of a possible 3284 citations for (1) data-driven analyses of the dimensions and factor structure of mania and bipolar depression and (2) longitudinal studies reporting real-time objective monitoring or momentary assessment of daytime activity in individuals with bipolar disorder compared with other clinical or healthy control samples. Hand search of reference lists, specialty journals, websites, published conference proceedings, and dissertation abstracts and contact with other researchers ensured inclusion of gray literature and additional analyses as well as raw data if appropriate. Quality assessment was perfomed using the National Institutes of Health quality assessment tool. FINDINGS: A total of 56 studies met eligibility criteria for inclusion in the review including 29 analyses of the factor structure of bipolar disorder, 3 of activity data from experimental sampling or ecological momentary assessment, and 20 actigraphy and 4 laboratory-based studies. Synthesizing findings across the studies revealed that the most robust finding was that mean levels of activity are lower during euthymia and depression in patients with bipolar disorder compared with healthy controls and other comparison groups (11 studies). The 7 ecological and laboratory studies show less organized or predictable patterns of behavior and a relative lack of habituation among patients with bipolar disorders compared with others. Factor analytic studies provide fairly consistent evidence that mood and activation represent distinct dimensions of bipolar disorder. Ten studies that examined interindividual and intraindividual patterns of activity suggest that mania may be better characterized by differences in robustness, variability, predictability, or complexity of activation rather than mean levels of activity. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: Within the limitations of the data, this synthesis of available evidence broadly supports the elevation of activation as a criterion A symptom for bipolar disorder in DSM-5. Although the importance of activation in bipolar disorders has been acknowledged for more than a century, this review suggests that this critical construct is understudied and should be the topic of more systematic high-quality research.
引用
- Scott J, Murray G, Henry C, et al. Activation in Bipolar Disorders: A Systematic Review. JAMA Psychiatry. 2017. PMID: 28002572. doi:10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2016.3459
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。